Supreme Court Allows Illinois to Keep Weapons Ban
Summary from the AllSides News Team
The U.S. Supreme Court declined gun rights advocates’ request to pause the enactment of an Illinois law, signed in January, that bans the sale of some semiautomatic weapons.
The Details: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit is currently considering the case, which will be heard on June 29. The advocates argued the law defies a precedent set in New York Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen which said gun control laws are only lawful if they are consistent with American traditions dating back to the founding of the nation.
For Context: The law bans some assault rifles, as well as the sale of magazines that have more than 15 rounds of ammunition for handguns. Citizens who legally owned affected weapons before the law’s enactment can keep them, but must register them with the state.
Key Quotes: Conservative Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito said gun rights advocates “should not be deterred,” and that the court’s decline to pause the law was over procedural matters, not based on the merits of the case.
How The Media Covered It: Some Left and Center-rated sources noted the conservative justices’ expansion of gun laws last summer and went more in-depth on context of mass shootings in relation to the law’s genesis. Right-rated sources covered Wednesday’s news similarly, but some went less in-depth on context. Some Right and Center-rated sources like Newsmax (Right bias) and The Hill (Center bias) posted Associated Press’ (Lean Left bias) wire as part of their coverage.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Supreme Court lets Illinois keep ban on sale of some semiautomatic guns for nowThe Supreme Court said Wednesday that Illinois can, for now, keep in place a new law that bars the sale of certain semiautomatic guns and large-capacity magazines.
The high court denied an emergency request from people challenging the law, which bans so-called assault weapons. The law’s opponents had asked the court to put the law on hold while a court challenge continues. The court did not comment and no justice publicly dissented.
The high court’s action comes at a time when gun violence has been heavily in the news. Since the beginning of...
From the Right
Supreme Court allows Illinois 'assault weapons' ban to take effectThe U.S. Supreme Court allowed Illinois' ban on "assault weapons" to take effect temporarily on Wednesday.
The ruling allows the Illinois law to remain in effect while lower courts deliberate on its constitutional status. Wednesday's ruling comes after a gun shop owner in Illinois requested an injunction against the ban.
The Illinois law bans the sale and new possession of semi-automatic "assault weapons." Those who already legally own such weapons would not have to turn them in. The law also bans the sale of large capacity magazines.
AllSides Picks
May 13th, 2024
May 13th, 2024