AllSides does not rate Newsmax TV; this rating is for its online, written content only. AllSides rates Newsmax opinion content separately.
Table of Contents
- Jan. 2021 Editorial Review: AllSides Keeps Newsmax Lean Right
- Dec. 2019 Editorial Review: AllSides Moves Newsmax from Right to Lean Right; Rates Newsmax Opinion Separately
- Third-Party Claims of Bias/Endorsement by President Donald Trump
- Jan. 2013 and March 2013 Blind Bias Surveys
- About Newsmax
Jan. 2021 Editorial Review: AllSides Keeps Newsmax Lean Right
The AllSides team noted that Newsmax often published wire content from Associated Press, Reuters, and other third-party outlets, which often have a diffferent bias than Lean Right — even Lean Left, as was the case for AP's political news content at the time.
The team did not find many examples of types of media bias such as sensationalism, spin, opinion statements presented as fact, or flawed logic, but found that overall Newmax's story choice was a clear Lean Right, amounting to bias by placement. On the day we reviewed, top articles included stories about cancel culture, Trump taking a final swipe at China, a story about a NY bill that would outlaw the sale and possession of body armor, and a story about a migrant caravan coming to the U.S. — all issues of interest on the right. However, our team was still able to identify numerous stories that would be of interest to folks on the left, such as a story about Dunkin' Donuts using compostable straws and a story about Eric Trump, Jr. being questioned by prosecutors.
Team members on the left and right noted that Newsmax does a good job of publishing full quotes from sources, not snippets or short segments of quotes taken out of context.
One left-wing team member said that Newsmax itself doesn't spin things, but the outlet "quotes people who spin things who are on the right." A team member in the Center said somthing similar, noting that, "The quotes they use are not as spun as we’ve seen elsewhere - they pick biased quotes or inflammatory quotes or base stories around those quotes."
Two team members who both have a Lean Left bias voted for Newsmax to have a Right bias rating. A team member with a Lean Right bias said he thought Newsmax was perhaps between Lean Right and Right, but that the outlet did not appear as far right as outlets such as Breitbart and TheBlaze.
A sampling of homepage headlines from summer 2020 were:
Lawyer Argues One of Fired Floyd Cops Was Rookie, Blasts Charges
Seattle Mayor Bans Tear Gas Use for 30 Days
Goodell Says NFL Was Wrong for Not Listening to Players
US Embassy in Mexico on Lockdown After Protests
Mayor Downplays Rough Police Treatment of NYC Protesters
Rep. Kinzinger to Newsmax TV: Defunding Police 'Nonsensical'
57 Resign From Buffalo Riot Response After Suspension
Minneapolis Agrees to Ban Police Chokeholds
A Look at Antifa, 'Boogaloo,' Others Blamed for Rioting
Supreme Court Could Make It Easier to Sue Police
Overall, the team opted to keep Newsmax's rating as Lean Right.
Third-Party Claims of Bias/Endorsement by President Donald Trump
Newsmax gained a lot of media attention around the Nov. 2020 presidential election after reports surfaced that Fox News viewers were abandoning the network and turning to Newsmax for information instead. President Donald Trump also touted Newsmax as a trustworthy alternative to Fox on Twitter.
A 2010 study conducted by Nielson, a media measurement and analysis company, found that Newsmax.com was the most-trafficked conservative website, with approximately 4 million unique monthly visitors, making it one of the most influential conservative websites in the nation.
Dec. 2019 Editorial Review: AllSides Moves Newsmax from Right to Lean Right; Rates Newsmax Opinion Separately
A Dec. 2019 editorial review of Newsmax's web content determined the site has a Lean Right bias. AllSides decided to rate Newsmax's opinion section separately, as its bias differed significantly from its news section.
Prior to Dec. 2019, AllSides rated Newsmax overall as Right. While Newsmax publishes a magazine, AllSides provides media bias ratings for web content only.
During our Dec. 2019 editorial review, a multipartisan team of reviewers found Newsmax's bias mostly lies in its story choice, primarily featuring stories that are generally of interest to conservatives. However, as the time of review, Newsmax did feature some stories that may be of interest to those on the left, such as a story about Michelle Obama praising Greta Thunberg. Our reviewers evaluated the types of bias Newsmax displayed and found the outlet did not add a lot of spin to its stories nor is its word choice sensationalist; Newsmax's bias largely lay in its story choice. Notably, the site featured a substantial amount of news reports from wire sources AllSides rated at the time as Center, such as Reuters and the Associated Press.
Jan. 2013 and March 2013 Blind Bias Surveys
Results from AllSides Blind Bias Surveys conducted in Jan. 2013 and March 2013 indicated that Newsmax's content was on the border of Lean Right and Right.
Newsmax Media is a conservative American news media organization founded by Christopher W. Ruddy. Based out of West Palm Beach, Florida, it operates on several platforms including Newsmax.com and Newsmax TV. The company was founded in 1998 and has been fairly consistent in generating positive revenue by targeting an audience of higher-income Baby Boomers.
Newsmax describes its magazine as one of the largest independent monthlies “with a conservative perspective.”