The Biden Admin Says Ukraine Will Join NATO, But Is It Realistic?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Ukraine’s chances of realistically joining NATO anytime soon have been marred by its territorial disputes and war with Russia, yet Secretary of State Antony Blinken said the nation eventually “will become a member.”
Background: The remark, which Blinken made in Brussels on Thursday, drew dialogue and criticism on social media and from some sources on the right.
A ‘Nonstarter’: An analysis from The New York Times (Lean Left bias) did not mention Blinken’s comment that Ukraine “will” join eventually, but called Ukrainian membership a “nonstarter” as it is mired in conflict with Russia. The analysis noted sentiments from officials that it won’t happen at the annual NATO summit this July and the currently grim outlook for Ukraine on the battlefield.
‘Reckless Rhetoric’: Jeremiah Poff of the Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) called Blinken’s comments “reckless rhetoric” considering how “seasoned” of a diplomat he is. Poff also noted the grim outlook for Ukraine and argued Blinken is “creating obstacles to negotiating peace” which would be in the best interest of the American and Ukrainian People.
Political ‘Nonsense’: Sumantra Maitra of The American Conservative (Right bias) called Blinken’s remarks “deeply cynical” and said U.S. and EU officials know membership cannot happen. He argued the Republicans are a “changed party,” citing objections to Blinken’s comments from notable GOP officials that he claims are in line with popular American sentiment. Maitra also said Blinken’s rhetoric is “purely for domestic consumption,” and creates a “false hope for Ukraine and Georgia… that may lead to their extinction as states.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
NATO Wants to Show Support for Ukraine, but Only So MuchWhen NATO’s leaders gather this summer to celebrate the 75th anniversary of their military alliance, the last thing they want to see is a resurgent Russian military marching across Ukraine because Europe was too weak to provide Kyiv with the support it needed.
What Ukraine wants, ultimately, is a formal invitation to join NATO. But alliance officials agree that is not going to happen at the festivities planned for Washington in July. NATO has no appetite for taking on a new member that, because of the alliance’s covenant of collective...
From the Right
Ukraine cannot join NATO, and Antony Blinken knows itFor someone who is as seasoned a diplomat as Secretary of State Antony Blinken is, the reckless rhetoric he displayed on Thursday was as disturbing as it was shocking.
After a meeting with Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba in Brussels on Thursday, Blinken told reporters that Ukraine was going to become a member of NATO without offering any qualifiers.
“Ukraine will become a member of NATO. Our purpose at the summit is to help build a bridge to that membership,” he said.
Kuleba followed up Blinken’s statement by saying, “Of course, we believe that Ukraine deserves...
From the Right
Antony Blinken Plays Politics with Ukraine’s NATO MembershipSecretary of State Anthony Blinken, reiterated that Ukraine will one day join NATO. It is a meaningless, almost theological gesture—practically pagan hymn-chanting at this point. Blinken knows his promise to be untrue. European allies know it to be untrue. The majority of Americans either don’t care about Ukraine or are actively opposed to further engagement in Europe. The Republicans are a changed party, as evident from thunderous responses from Republican senators. Ohio’s Senator J.D. Vance tweeted, “This is completely irresponsible. Ukraine should not join NATO, and to invite them during a war is to...
AllSides Picks
April 23rd, 2024
April 26th, 2024