After Jordan's Defeat, What's Next for House Republicans?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Why did Rep. Jim Jordan’s bid for the House Speaker position fail, and what does it mean for House Republicans?
Trump Tactics: A writer for CNN Opinion (Left bias) argued that Jordan’s attempts to “bully his opponents into a yes vote” were a method of politics learned from former President Donald Trump, who proved that “intimidation, bullying and political pressure” are effective tools. Jordan, however, “does not generate the same level of fear” as Trump, and House Republicans “don’t see him as the kind of person who could be trusted or counted on.”
Party Confusion: A Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) writer argued Republicans are struggling because the party is having “trouble deciding what it wants.” Comparing the current Republican-led House to the previous Democrat-controlled one, which had similarly thin margins, the writer argues, “Democrats have a stronger belief in their agenda than do Republicans. That makes it easier for Republican politicians to put television hits above the good of the party and the country.”
MAGA Backlash: Matt Lewis (Center bias) called Jordan’s failed bid a win for “team normal” and was “worth celebrating.” Determining that Jordan’s failed bid was not so much a sign of Republican dysfunction, but more an indication that the “adults finally showed up,” Lewis commended the Republicans that withheld support for Jordan, stating, “this does not mean the GOP has totally redeemed itself, it does mean that they have taken a crucial step back from the abyss of an almost entirely MAGA-dominated Republican Party.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Jim Jordan’s pressure campaign backfiredCongressman Jim Jordan’s plan to win the House speakership failed.
Over the past few days, Jordan tried to pressure fellow Republicans into voting for him. He mounted an intense campaign over the weekend to whip up the vote and undermine support for Louisiana Republican Steve Scalise.
On Tuesday, he called for a roll call vote. Knowing that he wouldn’t win on round one, Jordan hoped to bully his opponents into a yes vote. As voters saw the roll call, he could then count on pressure mounting within the districts.
But momentum...
From the Center
The House GOP Didn’t Just Reject Jim Jordan, They Made Him SquirmThe adults finally showed up. By derailing Rep. Jim Jordan’s bid to become Speaker of the House (at least until January, when he might run again), Republicans appear to have dodged a massive bullet on Thursday.
Sure, it was a small band of Republicans (22 on the second ballot) who rallied to stop Jordan—a man who was involved in Donald Trump’s attempt to overturn the 2020 election—from becoming speaker. But it was a much slimmer minority of Republicans who made Jordan’s ascension plausible in the first place.
And let’s be...
From the Right
Why the Republicans can't just get alongHouse Republicans’ inability to agree on a speaker has been blamed on the convergence of several factors: a narrow majority, the presence of some members who might very charitably be described as eccentrics, and the Freedom Caucus, which bills itself as more-principled-than-the-rest conservatives. But the leadership void is also being caused by the fact that the Republican Party has trouble deciding what it wants. And that is because the party’s ideology no longer produces conviction, even as members of Congress compete to claim the mantle of conservative purity.
It may...
AllSides Picks
April 30th, 2024
April 30th, 2024
April 29th, 2024
April 29th, 2024