Headline Roundup May 22, 2024
A Confusing Economy: Stocks Soar, But Americans' Outlook Remains Bleak
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Voices across the political spectrum are divided on the state of the American economy. How is the economy performing, and how is that performance impacting President Joe Bidenโs chances of winning reelection?
From the Left: A writer in The Atlantic (Left bias) determined Biden is โlosing his reelection campaignโ despite โpresiding over the strongest economy the United States has ever experienced.โ Despite pay increases, low unemployment, and cooling inflation, Biden is trailing former President Donald Trump in swing-state polls. The writer concluded that the main economic indicators โfail to account for some cloudier elements,โ stating, โAmericans remain stressed by, and ticked off about, high interest rates and high prices.โ Pointing to media outlets highlighting negative economic factors, partisan bias influencing perception, and the lingering impact of inflation, the writer concluded, โA strong economy did not save Trump from becoming a one-term president. It might not save Biden either.โ
From the Right: A writer in the Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) pushed back on claims that negative media coverage or Americansโ ignorance is slanting economic perceptions, stating, โWhen prices suddenly jump up by magnitudes entirely outside your experience โฆ and when they show no sign of falling back to familiar levels, you may be inclined to blame a national administration, particularly one that boasted of injecting vast sums into an economy that had high savings rates during the pandemic.โ The writer concluded, โa spell of persistent inflation leaves them feeling theyโre falling behind. No wonder โBidenomicsโ is a hard sell.โ
Featured Coverage of this Story

Illustration by The Atlantic. Source: Getty.
Joe Biden is, at the moment, losing his reelection campaign. And he is doing so while presiding over the strongest economy the United States has ever experienced.
The jobless rate is below 4 percent, as it has been for nearly two and a half years. Wage growth is moderating, but it is higher than it was at any point during the Obama administration; overall, Biden has overseen stronger pay increases than any president since Richard Nixon. Inflation has cooled off considerably, meaning that consumersโ purchasing power is strong.
Yet Bidenโs...

MarketWatch photo illustration/iStockphoto
It would apparently be a surprise to nearly half of American adults, but one of the U.S. stock marketโs major benchmarks is on track to post its strongest 100-day start to an election year on record.
With Thursday marking the 100th trading day of 2024, the S&P 500 SPX is up 11.6% so far this year โ its best first-100-day performance since 2021, when it rose 11.7% over the same stretch, according to Dow Jones Market Data.
If you want to explain to a puzzled left-leaning writer like the Atlanticโs Annie Lowrey why most voters this year rate the economy during Donald Trumpโs presidency more favorably than that during President Joe Bidenโs, you might start with a pair of simple charts.
Lowrey said the Biden years have seen โthe strongest economy the United States has ever experienced.โ She cited an unemployment rate below 4%, wage growth higher โthan at any point during the Obama presidency,โ and โstronger pay increasesโ than any in the last 50 years. Inflation,...