Meta, YouTube Must Pay $3 Million After Losing Social Media Addiction Trial

A jury in Los Angeles found Meta and YouTube liable in a trial that accused the social media platforms of being intentionally designed to get users addicted.

The Details: The plaintiff, a 20-year-old identified as KGM, argued that Instagram (owned by Meta) and YouTube were deliberately designed to be addictive and that the companies knew their platforms were harmful to young people. The jury found that Meta and Google, YouTube's parent company, should pay the plaintiff $3 million in damages. Meta will pay 70% of the amount, and Google the remaining 30%. Google has already said it plans to appeal the verdict. Separate proceedings will take place to determine the amount of additional punitive damages the companies should pay.

Arguments from Meta and YouTube: Meta's CEO Mark Zuckerberg said during questioning, "If people feel like they're not having a good experience, why would they keep using the product?" He also emphasized that the company has always prioritized keeping younger users safe.

For Context: This trial was a test case that is tied to about 2,000 other similar pending lawsuits from parents and school districts that have argued that social media giants need to be held responsible for "hooking a generation of young people to social media feeds," according to NPR (Lean Left bias).

How the Media Covered It: Coverage of the trial was similar across the political spectrum. NPR explored the details of how KGM's attorneys built their case to focus on platform design rather than content, which may have helped secure their win. Wall Street Journal (Center) reported details of both the plaintiff's arguments and arguments from Meta and Google to examine how the jury came to its verdict. The Journal also included a quote from lawyers representing some of the other social media cases linked to this trial, who said, "This verdict sends an unmistakable message that no company is above accountability when it comes to our children." Fox Business (Lean Right) reported similarities between this case and a trial in New Mexico that delivered a similar verdict to Meta on Tuesday.

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission. Suggest an improvement to this summary.