Skip to main content

Headline Roundup September 11th, 2024

Who Won the Trump-Harris Debate?

Summary from the AllSides News Team

Media outlets and pundits weighed in on who won last night's presidential debate in Philadelphia.

Vice President Kamala Harris: The New York Times (Lean Left bias) concluded that Harris succeeded in provoking Trump into veering off message, particularly when Harris suggested Trump's rallies were boring and when she mentioned Trump's criminal conviction and legal issues. National Review (Right bias) reported that Harris won the presidential debate, but that ABC assisted her by not fact-checking her during the debate while they fact-checked Trump about five times. Some pundits concluded Harris did not have convincing reasons for why her positions had changed on some economic issues.

Former President Donald Trump: Some media outlets noted Trump's statement that the withdrawal of the U.S. from Afghanistan resulted in equipment and resources being left behind, and Harris did not respond to the moderator's question on whether she felt responsible. He also reminded voters that Harris had supported fracking, and defunding the police. Trump also may have scored points when he pointed out that even with critics saying his tariffs would raise prices, he had low inflation when he was president. National Review concluded that Trump missed an opportunity to come out strong, and that he led himself down some "blind alleys" such as disputing crowd sizes and defending January 6 rioters.

In summary, many Trump allies are claiming victory, but many conservative commentators disagree. Some of the left said Harris won, but that it might not matter much.

The Harris campaign is already calling for another debate.

Featured Coverage of this Story

Trump’s Missed Opportunity
Trump’s Missed Opportunity

Brian Snuder/Reuters

Opinion

With an assist from ABC, Kamala Harris won the presidential debate in Philadelphia.

The moderators vigorously, and at times misleadingly, fact-checked Trump. He was right that Harris has in previous years come out for kicking 180 million Americans out of their private health plans and for confiscating guns. (The key word in ā€œmandatory buybacksā€ is the first.) They did not challenge her, letting her claim that his reference to a postelection ā€œbloodbathā€ was about civil strife rather than damage to the auto industry. They asked him more pointed questions than they asked her....

Open on National Review (Opinion)
Who Won the Debate? A Sharp Harris Rattled Trump
Who Won the Debate? A Sharp Harris Rattled Trump

Graham Dickie/The New York Times

News

In the first, and perhaps only, presidential debate between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald J. Trump, the two candidates verbally sparred in often deeply personal terms, with policy arguments largely being overshadowed by fiery exchanges over character and crowd size.

Political pundits, analysts and commentators noted that Mr. Trump had often found himself on the defensive on issues such as abortion while allowing himself to be baited by Ms. Harris and veering off message. The vice president belittled the attendance at Mr. Trump’s rallies and suggested that American military...

Open on New York Times (News)
Who Won the Trump-Harris Debate?
Who Won the Trump-Harris Debate?

AP

Opinion

Who came out on top, when Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump shared the stage for 90 minutes in Philadelphia? Members of the Journal’s editorial board react on the issues, the candidates’ presentations, standout moments and more.

Kim Strassel

Viewers hoping this debate would be the moment Kamala Harris finally had to answer for a dismal Biden-Harris record were sorely disappointed. Ms. Harris deftly changed the subject on nearly every direct question she was asked, and neither the moderators nor Donald Trump pressed her on the omissions.

Open on Wall Street Journal (Opinion)

More headline roundups

More News about 2024 Presidential Election on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right