Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 16th, 2024

Harris Accused of Plagiarizing Parts ofĀ 'Smart on Crime' Book

Summary from the AllSides News Team

Chris Rufo, a conservative activist and senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute (Lean Right bias), highlighted an analysis from Austrian "plagiarism hunter" Dr. Stefan Weber in which Weber says Harris' co-written 2009 book Smart on Crime: A Career Prosecutor's Plan to Make Us Safer contained 27 instances of plagiarism. 

The Details: Weber alleged that throughout the 248-page book, "24 fragments are plagiarism from other authors, [and] 3 fragments are self-plagiarism from a work written with a co-author." Several times, he alleges, they pulled verbatim text from a source without using quotation marks. In another instance, he said "Kamala Harris fabricated a source reference, inventing a nonexistent page number. The self-promotional content from Goodwill Industries was copied verbatim without citing the source."

How the Media Covered It: The story was covered widely on the right and less on the left. The New York Times (Lean Left) downplayed the allegations, naming only five of the examples Rufo cited without mentioning the other cases, and adding that the publisher of Plagiarism Today said that the "errors were not serious." He later said, "I was unaware of a full dossier with additional allegations, which led some to accuse the New York Times of withholding that information from me. However, the article clearly stated that it was my ā€˜initial reaction’ to those allegations, not a complete analysis," and added that the allegations were "more serious" than he initially believed. 

Featured Coverage of this Story

Kamala Harris 'Smart on Crime' Plagiarism Claims: Everything We Know
Kamala Harris 'Smart on Crime' Plagiarism Claims: Everything We Know

AFP/ Getty Images

News

Vice President Kamala Harris is under scrutiny due to allegations of plagiarism in a book that she coauthored in 2009.

According to a new report by Dr. Stefan Weber, Austrian "plagiarism hunter," Harris and co-author Joan O'C Hamilton had 27 "fragments of plagiarism" in the book Smart on Crime: A Career Prosecutor's Plan to Make Us Safer.

In the 49-page report, Weber and his team also allege that the Democratic presidential nominee and her coauthor copied and pasted from a Wikipedia article for the book.

Open on Newsweek
NYT plagiarism consultant admits Harris scandal 'more serious' than he thought
News

New York Times’ plagiarism consultant Jonathan Bailey released his "full analysis" of the allegations against Vice President Kamala Harris and found them "more serious" than he initially believed. 

"At the time, I was unaware of a full dossier with additional allegations, which led some to accuse the New York Times of withholding that information from me. However, the article clearly stated that it was my ā€˜initial reaction’ to those allegations, not a complete analysis," Bailey wrote on Plagiarism Today Wednesday. "Today, I reviewed the complete dossier prepared by Dr. Stefan Weber, whom I...

Open on Fox News Digital
Conservative Activist Seizes on Passages From Harris Book
Conservative Activist Seizes on Passages From Harris Book

Mike Lang/USA Today Network

News

The conservative activist Christopher Rufo published claims on Monday that Vice President Kamala Harris had copied portions of her 2009 book ā€œSmart on Crime,ā€ citing five sections that he said were lifted from widely available sites including Wikipedia and news reports.

The passages called into question by Mr. Rufo on his Substack platform involve about 500 words in the approximately 65,000-word, 200-page book. Ms. Harris, the Democratic presidential nominee, wrote the book with another author when she was the district attorney in San Francisco.

Open on New York Times (News)

More headline roundups

More News about 2024 Presidential Election on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right