Controversial Boxers Advance to Gold Medal Bouts at Paris Olympics
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Boxers Lin Yu-ting of Taiwan and Imane Khelif of Algeria advanced to gold medal bouts at the Paris Olympics amid widespread controversy regarding their gender.
Key Details: On Friday, Khelif will face Yang Liu of China in the welterweight division. On Saturday, Yu-ting will face Julie Szeremeta of Poland in the women's featherweight division.
Key Quotes: Khelif, through an interpreter, said, "I don't care about that {the controversy}. I wish to be ready and show a good standard, show my talent, because I want to entertain everyone.” Lin, through an interpreter, said, “I will use everything I’ve learned in my life to do my best in the next match.”
For Context: Khelif and Yu-ting were disqualified from the World Boxing Championships by the International Boxing Association (IBA) for reportedly failing gender eligibility tests in 2023 that indicated their "competitive advantages over other female competitors.” Some have questioned the verity of the IBA tests, and the IBA hasn't publicized the methodology.
How the Media Covered It: Both fighters have been framed as dominant by news sources across the spectrum, but with different connotations. The Associated Press (Lean Left bias) said Yu-ting and Khelif advanced despite "massive distractions" and "misconceptions" about their gender. The New York Post (Lean Right) said their "eligibility has been called into question."
Why the Difference? There is disagreement about whether Khelif and Yu-ting should be allowed to compete in women's boxing due to their alleged biological advantages.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Right
Imane Khelif dominates to advance to gold medal fight at Olympics amid gender controversyImane Khelif will fight for gold.
The Algerian boxer, whose eligibility has been called into question, advanced to the gold medal round of the women’s 66 kg welterweight division at the Paris Games, defeating Thailand’s Janjaem Suwannapheng by unanimous decision, 5-0.
Khelif won all three rounds, dictating the pace throughout the three-round bout.
While there was no moment at which Khelif appeared close to a knockout, even the most untrained eye could tell she was in control throughout, fighting with precision and landing punches more frequently than Suwannapheng.
From the Left
Lin Yu-ting advances to gold-medal Olympic bout, excelling amid misconceptions about her genderBoxer Lin Yu-ting of Taiwan has advanced to the gold-medal bout in the women’s featherweight division, winning her third consecutive bout while dealing with widespread scrutiny regarding misconceptions about her gender at the Paris Olympics.
One day after welterweight Imane Khelif of Algeria reached the women’s welterweight final with a third straight victory in Paris, Lin defeated Esra Yildiz Kahraman of Turkey 5:0 on Wednesday night for her third win.
Lin will fight for gold on Saturday, taking on Julia Szeremeta of Poland.
“I will use everything I’ve learned in my life to...
AllSides Picks
September 12th, 2024
September 12th, 2024
September 12th, 2024
September 11th, 2024