Skip to main content

Headline Roundup November 5th, 2024

How Has the Immigration Influx Impacted Schools?

Summary from the AllSides News Team

A recent Reuters (Center bias) survey found that a third of U.S. school districts said the increase in migrant children had a significant impact, leading to budget issues and language barriers. 

The Details: Of the 75 school districts surveyed across 23 states, 42 districts hired more English as a Second Language (ESL) instructors. According to Reuters, "11 respondents said - unprompted - that the newcomers had enriched the school community, bringing new perspectives and resilience that other children could learn from."

For Context:

  • New York City has enrolled nearly 40,000 new migrant children since 2022. The New York City Schools Chancellor said, "For some of the schools, the migrants coming here has been a godsend because we’ve lost so many other kids."
  • The Washington Post (Lean Left) highlighted the amazement of immigrants in Mohonasen Central School District in Rotterdam, New York, some of whom had never attended school consistently in their home countries. 
  • Denver Public Schools enrollment more than doubled between the 2022–23 and 2023–24 school years. The Chief Financial Officer at Aurora Public Schools (a suburb of Denver) said, “We’re running at 300% our normal, typical average for the school year.” 
  • Pennsylvania's Charleroi Area School District hired five new staff members to address the influx of Haitian immigrants, costing $400,000. After 37 students moved to the local charter school, the district paid an additional $500,000 for their tuition and transportation. 
  • According to WGN (Center) in Chicago Public Schools, "Some district administrators reportedly instructed several elementary school teachers to give migrant students passing grades even if the child displayed severe academic deficiencies."

How the Media Covered It: Outlets on the right were more likely to focus on lower standards in Chicago and strains on infrastructure due to immigration. Outlets on the left were more likely to mention the positive aspects of immigration as well, such as increased diversity in schools. 

Featured Coverage of this Story

Communities seeing influx of migrants facing real hurdles beyond ‘eating cats and dogs’
Analysis

Several cities across the country have been forced into the spotlight over publicized problems caused by surging immigration. While debunked theories have gone viral, deeper problems have immigration groups and elected officials worried.

Springfield, Ohio, is one such town. A spokesman from Gov. Mike DeWine’s (R-OH) office put his estimate of Haitian immigrants living in the city at 15,000, accounting for roughly a quarter of the town’s population. 

Open on Washington Examiner
Migrants Have Been a ‘Godsend,’ New York Schools Chief Says
Migrants Have Been a ‘Godsend,’ New York Schools Chief Says

Elias Williams for The New York Times

Analysis

As the school year opens for an American education system facing multiple crises, one education leader is staking out a curious stance. He is sublimely optimistic.

Public schools in the United States lost more than one million students between 2019 and 2022. The deluge of cash relief distributed during the coronavirus pandemic is drying up. And in a politically polarized era, fresh fights over what students learn in class are continuing to emerge.

Open on New York Times (News)
An American education: Classrooms reshaped by record migrant arrivals
An American education: Classrooms reshaped by record migrant arrivals

REUTERS/Carlos Barria

Analysis

Dana Smith had been teaching first grade at the public school in the small Pennsylvania town of Charleroi for more than 16 years when she found herself confronting a new challenge last year: a sharp rise in students from Haiti who did not speak English.

She started using a phone app to translate lessons, but the constant pauses for translation frustrated her. She wondered if she was hindering the learning of American students who knew some of the basics she was reviewing, a complaint raised by a vocal segment of...

Open on Reuters

More headline roundups

More News about Immigration on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right