What Does the Rise of Socialist Candidates Mean for the Democratic Party?

Over 30 socialist candidates have won primaries this year, sparking debate over socialism's place in the US and the future of the Democratic party. 

The Details: According to the Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias), the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) have endorsed 150 candidates this election cycle, with 35 wins and 34 losses. The most recent candidates included Darializa Avila Chevalier, Brad Lander and Claire Valdez – DSA members who were backed by New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani – who won in New York's congressional primaries. Other recent cities where DSA has helped candidates win city council positions include Seattle, Washington DC, Minneapolis, Chicago, Portland and Los Angeles.

The Rise of Socialism: Outlets across the political spectrum framed the recent wins as a "rebuke" or "challenge" to the Democratic establishment. Politico (Lean Left) wrote, "Democratic socialists just caused a political earthquake. Now they're coming for 2028…whether the party wants them or not." The Intercept (Left) argued, "The left isn't just having a moment — it's dictating how Democrats play the game of electoral politics." Washington Examiner said the wins in New York could set Mamdani up as a "kingmaker" in 2028. The Federalist (Right) argued that the wins reflect the impact of mass immigration that Americans were told for decades "would have little effect on the nation's political character." Fox News (Right) and Washington Times (Lean Right) shared several articles emphasizing the "dangers" of socialism and the extent of the socialist agenda. CNN (Lean Left) cited data that showed a growing percentage of Democrat voters who supported socialism and the popularity of Democratic socialists like Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY).

Voters Embrace Socialism: An analysis in Vox (Left) argued that the rise is a result of an "increasingly sclerotic Democratic establishment" that had become out of touch with voters, leaving them dissatisfied. The Associated Press (Lean Left) wrote that the rise comes amid "anti-Trump fervor" and as voters fee unheard by current Democratic lawmakers. It also said the revival is "partly a strategic move to align leftist ideas with concerns over affordability and the economy." CNN wrote that "packag[ing] and other attributes of the candidate" also matter when it comes to voter support of socialist candidates. A Washington Examiner opinion argued socialism is on the rise because one: cognitive dissonance, and two: "its faithful have worked diligently to erase its meaning," instead presenting it as compassion. Fox News interviewed Fox contributor Dan Bongino who said socialism is popular because it appeals to "imbeciles."

A Divided Democrat Party: Several left-leaning outlets explored the growing divide between moderate Democrats and Democratic socialists, with Left-Leaning outlets tending to favor arguments for a moderate Democrat party compared to outlets rated Left. CNN wrote that "just because Democrats are open to it doesn't mean it's good for their party brand." The New York Times (Lean Left) said the only faction happier than progressives were Republicans who are "eager to… define the Democratic brand by its most boisterous and socialist voices." It cited some Democratic leaders who urged candidates to move closer to the center to broaden its appeal. Another Politico article highlighted Democratic "fear" of "losing the party's ideological civil war — and hurting its electoral chances" this fall. Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) said the party was "drifting firmly into communism."

Meanwhile, the Intercept said that several races played out as proxy wars between establishment and progressive candidates, and progressives and socialists to prove who could better "disrupt the status quo." An opinion in USA Today (Lean Left) argued that the wins in New York were "terrific news" for those wanting a better future. The writer said that progressive Democrats won because "they're better candidates" who have a commitment to their beliefs and long-term vision for the Democratic Party.

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission. Suggest an improvement to this summary.