Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 3rd, 2024

Evidence Against Trump in 2020 Election Case Was Made Public. How Will It Affect the 2024 Election?

Summary from the AllSides News Team

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan made public Special Counsel Jack Smith's brief laying out the evidence against former President Trump in his 2020 election subversion case.

From the Left: MSNBC (Left bias) columnist Glenn Kirschner made the case that Trump's arguments about Smith changing his position were "empty allegations of hypocrisy" because Smith's circumstances changed due to Supreme Court directives. Kirschner argues that Trump's fillings hastened the process so that he might face justice for his actions on Jan. 6 sooner. "Trump’s new court filing made Chutkan’s job much easier. It was so unpersuasive that Chutkan simply set it aside, concluded that Smith’s proposed redactions struck the right balance and ordered his motion to be filed on the public record so she can move on to the litigation the Supreme Court has directed her to oversee," he said.

From the Right: Andrew C. McCarthy for the National Review (Right bias) argued that the right to a speedy trial applies to the defendant, but promptness isn't owed to the public. "There is nothing just about prosecutors’ filing four indictments against their party’s political rival with the objective of trying him before Election Day in a manner that gives him inadequate time to prepare for trial, let alone prepare for four trials," he said. He added that Chutkan was appointed by Obama and is likely sympathetic to the case against Trump. Even without a conviction, McCarthy says, "Smith’s allegations will be used by Democrats and repeated by the media as if they are established fact, the conclusions of a searching, exacting probe by a Justice Department special counsel."

Featured Coverage of this Story

One Month Before Election Day, Judge Chutkan Allows Jack Smith to Broadcast His Evidence
One Month Before Election Day, Judge Chutkan Allows Jack Smith to Broadcast His Evidence

Lindsay DeDario, Leah Millis/Reuters

Opinion

With 34 days to go before Election Day, and with early voting already under way in states that will decide the presidential contest, Judge Tanya Chutkan has granted Biden-Harris Justice Department special counsel Jack Smith’s motion to publicly broadcast the evidence he would offer at trial in the 2020 election-interference case against the Republican nominee, former President Donald Trump.

The ruling is no surprise — indeed, Rich and I anticipated it on the podcast last week.

Open on Andrew C. McCarthy
Trump tried to block Jack Smith’s immunity brief. It backfired.
Opinion

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan is about to wade into uncharted legal waters, deciding which of Donald Trump’s alleged election subversion crimes are official acts of an American president and hence at least presumptively immune from prosecution. The Supreme Court directed Chutkan to undertake this unprecedented litigation by creating out of whole cloth a doctrine of criminal immunity for a president’s “official acts.” On Tuesday, Trump’s lawyers made a last-ditch attempt to prevent this maiden legal voyage from setting sail. On Wednesday, that attempt backfired, as a brief from special counsel Jack Smith's...

Open on MS NOW

More headline roundups

More News about Donald Trump on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right