Judge Appoints Special Master in Mar-a-Lago Probe
AllSides Summary
A federal judge on Thursday denied the Justice Department’s motion to continue reviewing classified records seized from Mar-a-Lago, and appointed a special master to review the records.
The special master is Raymond Dearie, a 78-year old, recently retired judge. Former President Donald Trump's legal team requested that a special master be installed to sort through the seized documents and filter out any that were protected by attorney-client privilege or weren't government property. The DOJ had argued that it already completed a similar review; earlier this week, Trump's team said that the DOJ's probe had "spiraled out of control." Dearie was one of the candidates suggested by Trump whom the Justice Department didn't oppose.
In her order, Judge Aileen Cannon wrote that "the Court does not find it appropriate to accept the Government’s conclusions on these important and disputed issues without further review by a neutral third party in an expedited and orderly fashion." She gave Dearie a deadline of Nov. 30 to complete his work.
Some reports from left-rated sources, such as ABC News (Lean Left bias), highlighted how Cannon denied the DOJ's request to continue its review despite the fact that some of the seized documents bore "'SECRET' and 'TOP SECRET/SCI' markings." Some right-rated sources, such as Newsmax (Right bias), highlighted how Cannon ordered Trump's legal team to cover the costs of Dearie's work.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Right
New York judge Raymond Dearie appointed as special master in DOJ case against Trump

A veteran New York judge has been appointed to independently review the classified records seized from Donald Trump’s Florida resort last month and determine whether they fall under attorney-client privilege.
A veteran New York judge has been appointed to independently review the classified records seized from Donald Trump’s Florida resort last month and arbitrate the federal investigation into the former president.
Hon. Raymond Dearie was announced as special master in the case by US District Judge Aileen Cannon, court documents showed. Dearie was one of two possible third-party legal experts suggested to Cannon by Trump’s team....
From the Left
What to know about Judge Raymond Dearie, the Mar-a-Lago search special master
Judge Aileen Cannon has appointed Judge Raymond Dearie as the special master to review documents seized during a court-approved search of former President Donald Trump's Florida home in August.
Dearie, 78, a former chief judge of the federal court in the Eastern District of New York, was one of the special master candidates suggested by Trump whom the Justice Department did not object to.
Cannon directed Dearie to issue interim reports and recommendations "as appropriate" during the review and set a Nov. 30 deadline to complete his work. The Justice...
From the Center
Judge appoints special master, denying DOJ access to classified records
A federal judge on Thursday denied the Justice Department’s motion to access the classified records stored at Mar-a-Lago and installed a recently retired judge to serve as the special master former President Trump requested.
The duo of orders from federal district Judge Aileen Cannon will ignite a Department of Justice (DOJ) appeal to the 11th Circuit and also selects Judge Raymond Dearie to serve as the special master — the one candidate both the DOJ and Trump’s legal team could agree on.
The order requires Dearie to complete his review by Nov....
AllSides Picks

September 27th, 2023

September 26th, 2023

September 26th, 2023

More News about Justice from the Left, Center and Right
From the Left
From the Center
From the Right















