Headline Roundup June 26, 2024
SCOTUS Says States Lack Standing to Challenge WH Communications With Social Media Companies
Supreme Court,Social Media,Free Speech,Content Moderation,Censorship,Misinformation And Disinformation,Amy Coney Barrett,Samuel Alito,Federal State And Tribal Powers,Big Tech,Technology
Summary from the AllSides News Team
The Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday that a pair of Republican state attorneys general did not have grounds to sue the Biden administration over its communications with social media companies related to combatting pandemic-era misinformation.
Majority Opinion: Delivering the 6-3 majorityβs opinion, Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote that the plaintiffs challenging the Biden administration had not demonstrated βa substantial risk that, in the near future, they will suffer an injury that is traceable to a Government defendant and redressable by the injunction they seek,β thereby failing to establish standing. Thus, Barrett wrote, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals was βwrongβ to affirm βa sweeping preliminary injunctionβ against the Biden administration.
Alitoβs Dissent: In a dissenting opinion joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch, Justice Samuel Alito wrote that at least one plaintiff was βlikely to prevail on her claim that the White House coerced Facebook into censoring her speech,β because White House officials βwielded potent authorityβ in their βvirtual demands,β and βFacebookβs quavering responses to those demands show that it felt a strong need to yield.β
How the Media Covered It: Headlines from the right tended to label the case a βcensorship case,β with the New York Post (Lean Right bias) highlighting Alitoβs purportedly βfieryβ dissent β potentially appealing to the emotions of conservative readers opposed to the decision. On the other hand, headlines from mainstream outlets on the left tended to frame the case as less controversial, simply noting βWhite House contacts with social media firmsβ β potentially aligning with liberal attitudes that communications between the White House and social media companies were appropriate.
Featured Coverage of this Story

JACQUI VANLIEW; GETTY IMAGES
Today, the Supreme Court ruled in a 6β3 decision that the plaintiffs who'd sued the US government for allegedly violating the First Amendmentβby communicating with social media companies about misleading and harmful content on their platformsβdid not present enough evidence to prove that they had standing to sue.
The case was brought by the attorneys general from Louisiana and Missouri, who alleged that government agencies have had undue influence on the content moderation practices of platforms and coerced the platforms into taking down conservative-leaning content, infringing on the First Amendment rights of their citizens....

Eric Lee/The New York Times
The Supreme Court handed the Biden administration a major practical victory on Wednesday, rejecting a challenge to its contacts with social media platforms to combat what administration officials said was misinformation.
The court ruled that the states and users who had challenged the contacts had not suffered the sort of direct injury that gave them standing to sue.
The decision, by a 6 to 3 vote, left fundamental legal questions for another day.
βThe plaintiffs, without any concrete link between their injuries and the defendantsβ conduct, ask us to conduct...

OLIVIER DOULIERY/AFP via Getty Images
The Supreme Court on Wednesday ruled in favor of the Biden administration in a challenge to its alleged coordination with social media companies, saying that the states who sued the administration lacked standing.
The case, Murthy v. Missouri, stems from a lawsuit brought by state attorneys general from Missouri and Louisiana that accused high-ranking government officials of working with giant social media companies "under the guise of combating misinformation" that ultimately led to censoring speech on topics that included Hunter Bidenβs laptop, COVID-19 origins and the efficacy of face masks.
Justice Amy...
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Muslims Projected to Outnumber Christians by 2035: Report
November 19th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Fuel Prices Fall After Midterms, Prompting Debate Over What Drove the Decline
November 19th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Trump, Xi and Putin Hold Historic Summit, Issue Joint Declaration on Global Security
November 19th, 2026
Blog
Technology Outages Affect Banking, Transportation, and Tech Sectors
AllSides Staff
November 19th, 2026
More News about Supreme Court on AllSides
News from the Left
News from the Center
News from the Right
CNBC