Skip to main content

Headline Roundup July 10th, 2019

Court of Appeals: Trump Cannot Block Critics on Twitter

Summary from the AllSides News Team

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that President Donald Trump cannot "block" other users on Twitter.

The ideologically diverse court decided that Twitter is a public platform where voters communicate with their elected officials. The court went on to say that any blocking of users can be deemed silencing dissent, thus infringing on the First Amendment.

Left-leaning media has focused on Trump's use of Twitter to degrade opponents and foes, while also fighting in court to block users who oppose him. However, some on the left deemed the court ruling to be "unpersuasive." The right seems to hold both disappointment and enthusiasm, speculating that Trump may take this case to the Supreme Court.

Featured Coverage of this Story

U.S. Appeals Court Rules Trump Violated First Amendment By Blocking Twitter Followers
U.S. Appeals Court Rules Trump Violated First Amendment By Blocking Twitter Followers

NPR (Online News)

News

A federal appeals court in Manhattan says President Trump cannot block critics from his Twitter account, calling it "unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination."

In a 29-page ruling on Tuesday, a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously upheld a lower court's decision that found that Trump violated the First Amendment when he blocked certain Twitter users, because he uses his Twitter account "to conduct official business and to interact with the public." By preventing critics from accessing his feed, the president is barring them from participating in what...

Open on NPR (Online News)
A court rules (unpersuasively) that Trump can't block critics on Twitter
A court rules (unpersuasively) that Trump can't block critics on Twitter

Los Angeles Times

Opinion

A federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday that President Trump violated the 1st Amendment by blocking some critics from access to his Twitter feed. The decision by the U.S. 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals might seem like poetic justice visited on a president who can dish it out but can’t take it. But as a matter of constitutional law, the ruling isn’t persuasive.

In 2017, a group of Twitter users who had been blocked from seeing and responding directly to Trump’s tweets filed suit in federal court in New York....

Open on Los Angeles Times
OPINION: The Second Circuit Court of Appeals Was Wrong to Rule That Trump Can’t Block Twitter Users
OPINION: The Second Circuit Court of Appeals Was Wrong to Rule That Trump Can’t Block Twitter Users

National Review (News)

Opinion

Earlier today the Second Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously that Donald Trump cannot block Twitter users from following his @realDonaldTrump account. It’s an interesting decision from an ideologically diverse judicial panel that at first glance appears to be a straightforward application of conventional First Amendment law. It’s also wrong. It makes a crucial error that reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of speech on private social-media platforms.

Boiled down to its essence, the court’s reasoning contained two key elements. First, it ruled that Trump’s Twitter account represents an outlet for official...

Open on Guest Writer - Right

More headline roundups

More News about Justice on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right