Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 17th, 2024

Bipartisan Panel Says Secret Service Needs Reform 

Summary from the AllSides News Team

An independent review of the Secret Service following the first assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump concluded the need for "fundamental" changes.

The Details: The panel, made up of government officials and former law enforcement, said that without change, what happened in Butler, PA, would happen again. The report found there was no plan to secure key buildings before the Butler rally, and there were communications breakdowns internally and with local police. The 52-page report recommended that the Secret Service de-emphasize investigating financial crimes, have overhead surveillance at outdoor events, have at least one representative of the Secret Service and state and local law enforcement at a communications hub, and bring in outside leadership. The changes should be made by March.

Key Quote: The panel said, "The Secret Service has become bureaucratic, complacent, and static even though risks have multiplied and technology has evolved." 

For Context: The panel traveled to Butler, reviewed 58 multi-hour interviews of the Secret Service and law enforcement, and reviewed more than 7,000 documents. They did not find lack of funding to be one of the underlying issues. The assassination attempt in Butler led to the resignation of the Secret Service director. The Secret Service thwarted another attempt on Trump's life at his golf course in September.

How the Media Covered It: Some media coverage used sensational language or subjective adjectives. BBC News (Center bias) said the report was "damning," and Politico (Lean Left) said the review "blasts" the Secret Service.

Featured Coverage of this Story

Review says U.S. Secret Service 'complacent', needs reform
Review says U.S. Secret Service 'complacent', needs reform

REUTERS/Brendan McDermid/File Photo

News

he U.S. Secret Service has become bureaucratic and complacent and is in need of reform, an independent review into the first assassination attempt on Donald Trump concluded on Thursday, saying without change such an incident will happen again.

On July 13, Trump, the Republican candidate in the Nov. 5 presidential election, narrowly escaped being shot in the head in Butler, Pennsylvania, by a bullet that grazed his ear.

The near-miss exposed serious security gaps and led to heightened protection measures for Trump's outdoor rallies.

Open on Reuters
Independent review finds systemic Secret Service failures enabled first Trump assassination attempt
Independent review finds systemic Secret Service failures enabled first Trump assassination attempt

Jabin Botsford / The Washington Post via Getty Images file

News

An independent, bipartisan review identified “numerous mistakes” by the U.S. Secret Service and “specific failures and breakdowns” that enabled the assassination attempt that injured former President Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, in July.

The panel, made up of four former senior law enforcement and government officials, also warned of another catastrophic security lapse if the Secret Service does not immediately undertake “fundamental reform.”

Open on NBC News Digital
Secret Service needs 'fundamental' changes or 'another Butler can and will happen again': panel
Secret Service needs 'fundamental' changes or 'another Butler can and will happen again': panel

Fox News Digital

News

A bipartisan panel condemned the Secret Service's handling of former President Donald Trump's rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, on Thursday, saying the agency needs "fundamental" changes to be effective. The panel, made up of former senior law enforcement and government officials, warned that if there are not extensive reforms at the Secret Service, then "another Butler can and will happen again." Butler, Pennsylvania, was the site of the first assassination attempt against Trump this year. The Secret Service faced heavy criticism for negligence and sluggish reaction speed.

Open on Fox News Digital

More headline roundups

More News about Defense and Security on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right