Daniel Penny trial judge agrees to drop top manslaughter count after jury deadlocks twice
Manhattan prosecutors were forced to take the drastic step of tossing the top charge against Daniel Penny Friday after jurors twice said they couldn’t agree on a verdict in the highly watched subway chokehold case.
The note from jurors stating that they were deadlocked on the count of manslaughter in the second-degree sparked a dizzying and dramatic back-and-forth that ended with Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Maxwell Wiley agreeing to dismiss the rap.
“I’ll take a chance and grant the people’s application,” Wiley said, instructing the jury to return Monday and deliberate the charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a lighter sentence.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Chicago-Area Man Sentenced to Two Years in Prison for Fake Robbery Immigration Scam
October 27th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Mississippi Releases Bodycam Footage of Police Shooting That Killed 1-Year-Old Kohen Wiley
October 26th, 2026
The Insight: Where Does America Stand on the Death Penalty?
AllSides Staff
October 16th, 2026
News
Tracking Trump’s Campaign Promises
AllSides Staff
October 2nd, 2026