Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 1st, 2019

Judge Rules Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions Process is Constitutional

Summary from the AllSides News Team

A legal challenge to Harvard University's race-conscious admissions process was defeated by a federal judge in Boston on Tuesday. The lawsuit alleged that Harvard capped admission for Asian-Americans while seeking to balance its admissions on an ethnic basis. Some left-leaning media reported that the decision was expected due to many other universities using similar processes; some right-leaning outlets were more critical of diversity supposedly taking priority over academic qualifications.

Featured Coverage of this Story

Harvard wins bid to keep race as factor in admissions process
Harvard wins bid to keep race as factor in admissions process

New York Post (News)

News

A federal judge ruled Tuesday that Harvard can continue to use race as a factor in its admissions process.

An anti-affirmative-action group, Students for Fair Admissions, sued the Ivy League university in 2014, arguing that the school was admitting members of under-represented ethnic groups at the expense of more qualified Asian-Americans.

But Judge Allison Burroughs wrote in her decision, “Harvard’s admission program passes constitutional muster,” according to NPR.

“Ensuring diversity at Harvard relies, in part, on race-conscious admissions,” Burroughs added.

The student group is expected to appeal, and experts predict...

Open on New York Post (News)
Harvard Defeats Suit Seeking to Bar Race-Conscious Admission
Harvard Defeats Suit Seeking to Bar Race-Conscious Admission

Bloomberg

News

Harvard University defeated an anti-affirmative action group’s lawsuit to stop the school from using race as a factor in admissions, in a ruling that’s likely to be challenged all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

A federal judge on Tuesday ruled that the nation’s oldest college doesn’t discriminate against Asian-Americans, as the suit claimed, and that its consideration of race as one criterion among many in its admissions decisions is lawful. The suit, brought in 2014 by Students for Fair Admissions, claimed that Harvard illicitly engaged in “racial balancing”...

Open on Bloomberg
Federal judge rules Harvard does not discriminate against Asian Americans in admissions
Federal judge rules Harvard does not discriminate against Asian Americans in admissions

Washington Post

News

A federal judge ruled Tuesday that Harvard University does not discriminate against Asian Americans in undergraduate admissions, handing the school a victory in a lawsuit that marks one of the latest chapters in the affirmative action debate.

U.S. District Judge Allison D. Burroughs rejected claims of a plaintiff that Harvard violates the law as it considers race in selecting an incoming freshman class. While Harvard’s “admissions process may be imperfect,” Burroughs wrote, the judge concluded that statistical disparities among racial groups of applicants “are not the result of any racial...

Open on Washington Post

More headline roundups

More News about Education on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right