Skip to main content

Headline Roundup May 16th, 2023

The Durham Report: FBI Incompetent or Compliant With Clinton?

Summary from the AllSides News Team

Does Special Counsel John Durham’s report show mismanagement of intelligence or blatant compliance with the Clinton campaign?

For Context: In a 306-page report, Durham criticized the FBI's investigation into alleged ties between Russia and the 2016 Trump campaign as lacking “analytical rigor.”

No ‘Provable Criminal Offense’: An analysis by CNN (Lean Left bias) highlights that Durham found “a significant intelligence failure,” but wouldn’t be able to prosecute anyone for their actions. It also mentions that in the report, Durham included a quote from an interview he conducted with Hillary Clinton where she dismissed the investigation as a “rabbit hole.”

Strategic Compliance: An opinion writer for National Review (Right bias) argues the FBI wasn’t ignoring a “plan” by Clinton to “smear” Donald Trump, then the Republican nominee, but willfully abetted her efforts. They say the move to assist Clinton was strategic, as the bureau “fully expected Clinton to be the next president,” and wouldn’t want to deal with a president who would be “vengeful against the FBI.”

Inexcusable Public Collusion: An opinion writer for Newsweek (Center bias) argues the report doesn’t “exonerate Trump’s actions when it comes to Russia,” saying his public request of Russia to produce emails from Clinton “may not have risen to the level of secret collusion… making it a hazy First Amendment issue.” Editor's Note: We replaced an article from Newsweek we had originally used in the comparison below, as it didn't reflect a Center point of view on this story.

Featured Coverage of this Story

From the Right
The FBI Didn’t Ignore Russian Intel on Hillary’s Plan to Smear Trump — It Abetted the Plan
The FBI Didn’t Ignore Russian Intel on Hillary’s Plan to Smear Trump — It Abetted the Plan

Jonathan Ernst, David 'Dee' Delgado/Reuters

Opinion

Among the most troubling conclusions in special counsel John Durham’s Russiagate report is that the FBI — even as it relied on Clinton-campaign-funded opposition research against Donald Trump that it failed to verify — ignored strongly supported intelligence that Hillary Clinton was intentionally smearing Trump as a Putin puppet.

To my mind, Durham is being too kind.

Perusing the report, I find it impossible to draw any other conclusion than that the FBI, and the Obama administration more broadly, did not ignore the intelligence about Clinton’s strategy but rather that the law-enforcement and intelligence apparatus...

Open on National Review (News)
Possible Paywall
From the Center
Durham Report: Analysts React To Findings 'Devastating' FBI Over Trump-Russia Collusion Probe
Durham Report: Analysts React To Findings 'Devastating' FBI Over Trump-Russia Collusion Probe

REUTERS / DAVID GRAY

Analysis

Observers and political analysts have commented on the long-awaited report of special counsel John Durham, which looked into the purported scheme to link former president Donald Trump to Russia in 2016, with some saying the report exonerated him in a way.

Durham's 316-page report released Monday revealed the FBI shouldn't have initiated an investigation into the supposed connections between the Trump 2016 campaign and Russia. It added the federal investigators did not secure "any actual evidence of collusion" between the former president and Russia before the probe was launched.

Durham's office conducted over 480...

Open on International Business Times
From the Left
Durham interviewed Hillary Clinton on alleged plan to tie Trump to Russia, found no ‘provable criminal offense’
Durham interviewed Hillary Clinton on alleged plan to tie Trump to Russia, found no ‘provable criminal offense’

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

News

Special counsel John Durham’s report released Monday details his investigation of a purported effort by Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign to tie Donald Trump to Russia but which Durham concludes “did not, all things considered, amount to a provable criminal offense.”

Durham reveals in a footnote that he interviewed the former secretary of State in May 2022 as part of his investigation.

The special counsel was looking into whether any crimes occurred in the handling of an uncorroborated piece of US intelligence indicating Russia knew of a Clinton campaign plan to...

Open on CNN Digital

More headline roundups

More News about Donald Trump on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right