Trump’s Pennsylvania lawsuits invoke Bush v. Gore — but SCOTUS probably won’t decide the election
Elections,2020 Election,Donald Trump,Joe Biden,Rudy Giuliani,Election Law
The Trump campaign has filed two lawsuits in federal court over ballot counting and voting deadlines in Pennsylvania, threatening to take the election to the Supreme Court. Both consciously echo the two main legal theories of Bush v. Gore, the infamous Supreme Court case that decided the contested 2000 presidential election.
But this race is not likely to be decided by the Supreme Court. There are several reasons, sitting at the intersection of law and politics, why the ghosts of Florida past won't rise again in Pennsylvania. As a law professor who's authored a book on election reform, I rate success in Trump's efforts to wrench back Biden's lead through litigation as a real long shot, though not out of the question.
Equal protection
Trump's latest Pennsylvania lawsuit draws on the "equal protection" argument cited in Bush v. Gore.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Trump Says He'd Consider Pardons For Allies If Democrats Win Midterms
November 2nd, 2026
Headline Roundup
Supreme Court Rejects Trump Admin Request to Set Aside 20k CA Ballots
November 2nd, 2026
Story of the Week
Elections in Brazil, Israel, and Serbia
AllSides Staff
October 29th, 2026
Opinion
About 3% of American 'Supervoters' Could Decide the Midterms. Are You One of Them?
Guest Writer
October 15th, 2026