Supreme Court Allows Idaho Ban on Gender-Affirming Care for Children While Legislation is Challenged
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
The Supreme Court’s confusing new anti-trans decision, explainedThe Supreme Court handed down a strange set of opinions on Monday evening, which accompanied a decision that largely reinstates Idaho’s ban on gender-affirming care for minors. The ban was previously blocked by a lower court.
None of the opinions in Labrador v. Poe spend much time discussing whether such a ban is constitutional — although Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s concurring opinion does contain some language suggesting that he and Justice Amy Coney Barrett will ultimately vote to uphold the ban.
Rather, seven of the nine justices split into three different...
From the Right
Supreme Court Allows Idaho Law Protecting Children From Transgender Procedures To Go Into EffectThe Supreme Court ruled Monday to allow an Idaho law protecting children from life-altering transgender procedures to go into effect while the law is challenged in lower courts.
The law, passed last year, bans procedures like double mastectomies on girls who identify as boys and giving children puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, which have been linked to bone development issues and heart problems. The law also stipulates that doctors who perform transgender procedures on kids could go to prison for 10 years. The decision means the law will go into...
From the Center
Supreme Court Allows Idaho’s Gender-Affirming Care Ban — For NowThe Supreme Court on Monday allowed Idaho to enforce a controversial ban on gender-affirming care to minors as the law is appealed, temporarily reintroducing one of more than a dozen state bans on gender-affirming care, an increasingly hot-button issue for the GOP.
The Supreme Court approved a stay on a federal District Court decision, allowing Idaho to enforce the ban, with the high court’s conservative justices forming the majority opinion and its three liberal justices dissenting.
The Supreme Court’s ruling comes three months after a U.S. District Court upheld a...
AllSides Picks
April 30th, 2024
April 29th, 2024