Does Charlie Kirk's Assassination Portend More Political Violence?

Deep Rot In The Democrat Party: Following the “horrific assassination” of Charlie Kirk, opinion writer for American Thinker (Right bias), Mike Robertson said, “one might have expected America’s legacy media and Democrat-leaning outlets to rally around basic human decency.” Robertson said, “Instead [it] was a demonstration of insensitivity, subtle approvals, outright laughter, and conspiracy-mongering that exposed (again) the deep rot in the Democratic party.” Robertson utilized MSNBC (Left) analyst Matthew Dowd for one example of this, who was fired after saying Kirk’s “hateful words” had inevitably led to “hateful actions.” Furthermore, Robertson said MSNBC’s Katy Tur “fram[ed] the assassination as some karmic consequence of his [Kirk’s] bold conservatism.” According to Robertson, “This isn’t reporting, its advocacy for violence against anyone who challenges the woke establishment,” and “Americans deserve better than this bile from so-called public servants in the media.”

What Have We Become: Opinion writer for The Guardian (Left) Ed Pilkington said following the assassination, a “nation already grappling with polarization faces shock bordering on despair.” Pilkington said that although Kirk “expressed openly bigoted views and engaged in homophobic and Islamophobic rhetoric” mixed with “evangelical Christian beliefs,” making a “combustible brew,” mourning for his loss “crossed the political aisle.” Kirk’s death “leaves the US standing on the edge of a new abyss,” with the safety of public figures and sanctity of public debate at risk. Pilkington, calling Kirk “the golden boy of the Maga movement,” said his identity “raises the stakes dramatically.” The article ended with fears expressed by progressive influencer Hasan Piker, who said "The reverberation of people seeking out vengeance in the aftermath of this violent, abhorrent incident is going to be genuinely worrisome.” 

Assassination Culture Spreading On The Left: Charlton Allen, also an opinion writer for American Thinker, explained Kirk “gave voice, fellowship, and a steady anchor in rough waters” to “young conservatives marooned on hostile [college] campuses,” and “now that voice has been stolen.” Kirk warned on X in April 2025 that an “assassination culture is spreading on the left,” and Allen said this warning “returns to haunt us.” Allen warned “Kirk’s assassination must mark a national inflection point” to “recover the civic virtue [which] in times past [was] such a vital part of the American ethos.” Will we return to the “belief that citizens may disagree, even passionately, without resorting to violence,” or “will we surrender to a hellscape where voices are silenced for their point of view, where the bullet replaces the ballot?”

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission. Suggest an improvement to this summary.