MLB Approves Robot Umpire Challenge System. Is It Good for Baseball?

Major League Baseball (MLB) announced that it will implement an electronic umpiring system in 2026, allowing pitchers, catchers, and batters to challenge a human umpire's pitch calls.

The Details: Teams will get two challenges per game, and players will be able to trigger the Automated Ball-Strike (ABS) Challenge System by tapping their helmet or cap. The challenge will prompt an animated replay using Hawk-Eye technology that will show the location of the pitch to spectators. The decision to implement the technology was approved 9-2 by the MLB’s Joint Competition Committee, which includes six owners, four players, and an umpire. The two dissenting votes came from a player and the umpire.

Impersonal Society: David Murphy of The Philadelphia Inquirer (Lean Left bias) said baseball “has always been built on a bedrock of resistance to change” and that “for the last 122 years, Major League Baseball has served as an important cultural counterweight to the spirit of progress coursing through the rest of modern-day life.” Murphy claimed he’s “fully on board with baseball’s new system” but suspects the resistance to it is “rooted in the inherent tension of the digital age,” where “all of us recognize the corrosive societal effects of the technologies that have replaced human-to-human interaction.” He concluded, “At the same time… I understand if people view ABS as one more step down the slippery slope to total impersonality. Maybe I’m just getting old.”

Not Enough: Rich Lowry (Right) of National Review (Right) and Michael Rand of The Minnesota Star Tribune (Lean Left) both suggested that the MLB’s decision doesn’t go far enough. Lowry wrote, “[ABS] is welcome but insufficient. Human umpiring of balls and strikes is a travesty that is terrible for the game.” Rand argued the challenge system will “interrupt the flow of the game” and prevent fans from knowing “for sure if they can celebrate a play in real-time, knowing that a review might change the outcome.”

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission.