Media Report Hamas’ Claim of 31 Civilians Massacred in Gaza, Israel Says 'Allegations' are ‘False’

Many mainstream media outlets reported 31 people were killed and over 170 wounded in Gaza on Sunday when Israeli forces opened fire towards a crowd of people receiving humanitarian aid, though Israel has described the “allegations” as “false.”

Gaza’s Claim: Many mainstream outlets cited the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry, the International Committee of the Red Cross, and/or other witnesses as sources for the claims of the mass killing. 

Aid Foundation’s Rebuttal: The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), which is backed by Israel and the United States, said it delivered the aid “without incident” and released a video showing aid distribution that it claims was from the site on Sunday.

Israeli Statements: According to The Times of Israel (Center bias), an Israeli official said troops fired warning shots overnight about a kilometer away from the site before it opened to distribute aid: “IDF troops worked to prevent a number of suspects from approaching the forces. During the activity, warning shots were fired at a number of suspects who approached the forces. There is no connection between the incident in question and the false allegations against the IDF.” The IDF also published a video it said was of masked gunmen shooting Gazans trying to collect aid.

How The Media Covered It: The original claim from Gaza’s Health Ministry was widely reported by mainstream media outlets like Associated Press (Left), CNN (Lean Left), BBC News (Center), Sky News (Lean Left), and more. Several outlets have since updated headlines and coverage to reflect Israel’s denial of the claims. Al Jazeera (Lean Left) gave less air to denials in its coverage and noted just once that the GHF, which it described as “controversial,” denied the claims. Other outlets highlighted denials more prominently in updated coverage.

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission.