Fact Check: Is Trump Being Denied a Jury in His New York Civil Trial?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Donald Trump claimed he is being denied a jury in his $250 million civil fraud trial in New York court. Is this true?
Details: Trump is facing civil fraud charges brought forth by New York Attorney General Letitia James. James alleges that Trump “falsely inflated his net worth to enrich himself and cheat the system.” The case is a bench trial, meaning there is no jury, and the judge— Justice Arthur F. Engoron— controls the proceedings and rules on the case.
Trump’s Claim: On Wednesday, Trump told reporters, “this witch-hunt does not allow me to have a jury,” adding, “I'm not entitled to a jury — because if I had a jury, even though it's in New York and I think I'd do fine with New York — if I had a jury, I would win this case very easily, but I don't have a jury.”
“Checking a Box”: A number of voices and outlets pushed back on Trump’s claim that he was being denied a jury, arguing that Trump’s legal team failed to “check a box” on a court filing requesting a jury. Snopes (Lean Left bias) slightly rebuked these arguments, outlining the legal process of requesting a jury in New York court and determining that it’s true “that the Trump team did not try to assert a right to a jury trial under N.Y. CPLR 4102. It is also true, however, that being awarded a jury trial would have been much more complicated than simply ‘checking a box.’”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Did Trump's Lawyers 'Forget To Check a Box' Requesting a Jury Trial?On Oct. 2, 2023, former U.S. President Donald Trump appeared, in person, to witness the proceedings in a case brought by New York City Attorney General Letitia James against his business empire. James accused Trump's businesses and business associates of "persistent and repeated business fraud." The case, notably, is a bench trial in which a single judge, Justice Arthur F. Engoron, not only controls the proceedings but ultimately rules on the facts of the case as well.
In a "makeshift" press conference held during a break in the first day's...
From the Center
Fact-checking Trump's claims about New York fraud trialDonald Trump made a passionate opening statement, of sorts, on the first day of his fraud trial in New York.
The former president was not giving evidence - instead, he stopped just outside the courtroom to address reporters before the historic hearing began.
After a few stern looks at the camera, he launched into a lengthy preview of what his lawyers are expected to argue during the civil case again him, his two adult sons and the Trump Organization.
He also lobbed accusations against New York Attorney General Letitia James,...
From the Right
Trump: This Is a 'Railroading,' 'Does Not Allow Me a Jury'While mainstream media sought to disparage former President Donald Trump's legal team for not opting for a jury trial, Trump said not being given the option was "railroading" and another way "they've weaponized justice in our country."
"This witch-hunt that's going on, using statute 63(12) — which is a consumer-fraud statute, which may be unconstitutional — doesn't allow me a jury, doesn't allow me anything," Trump told reporters before entering the courtroom on Day 3 of New York Democrat Attorney General Letitia James' $250 million civil trial against him.
AllSides Picks
May 4th, 2024
May 7th, 2024