Experts Say Democratic Video Not 'Seditious,' as Trump Claims
Facts And Fact Checking,Democratic Party,Video,Defense And Security,Treason
After six congressional Democrats released a video advising members of the U.S. military and national security community to "refuse illegal orders," President Donald Trump said the lawmakers should be tried in court for "SEDITIOUS BEHAVIOR, punishable by DEATH!" But legal experts told us this was not sedition and that the legislators were restating the law that only lawful orders must be followed.
"Sedition is trying to overthrow the government with force or violence," Eric R. Carpenter, a professor of law at Florida International University College of Law, said in an email to us. "In the video, the elected officials are just telling service members to follow the law. They are not telling service members to overthrow the government."
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Red Blue Translator
Facts
Red Blue Translator
Disagreement
Announcement
Weβre Bringing Ads Back β But You Can Turn Them Off For Free
John Gable, AllSides Co-founder
June 1st, 2026