Opinion Why the Supreme Court’s immunity ruling is untenable in a democracy
Supreme Court,Presidential Immunity
Under the Supreme Court’s recent ruling on presidential immunity, could President Richard M. Nixon have legally ordered his Plumbers to burgle the office of Daniel Ellsberg’s psychiatrist? Might they all have gotten away with it?
It certainly looks that way to me, and I have a particular interest in this matter. As a young lawyer in the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office in 1971, I oversaw the burglary indictment of senior White House officials and White House operatives for breaking into the Beverly Hills office of Dr. Lewis Fielding. In my assessment, if Trump v. U.S. had been on the books then, the president’s agents responsible for the Fielding burglary and related crimes, instead of going to prison, would have escaped prosecution and punishment entirely.
Let me explain why. In its June ruling, the Supreme Court held for the first time that a former president cannot be prosecuted for any acts undertaken while in office if those acts fall within the core constitutional powers of the presidency even if they constitute prima facie crimes under the federal criminal code. Other official acts outside that core responsibility, the court said, are at least presumptively immune.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Could There Be More Behind Jensen Huang's Resignation Than Extramarital Affairs?
November 15th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Trump, Putin and Xi Plan Historic Three-Way Summit in China
November 14th, 2026
The Insight
Is America’s homelessness crisis improving?
AllSides Staff
November 13th, 2026
Recommended Reading
Where ‘Blue’ Voters Crossed Partisan Lines During the Midterm Elections
AllSides Staff
November 13th, 2026
More News about Supreme Court
News from the Left
News from the Center
News from the Right
CNBC