Is Presidential Immunity in the Constitution?
Supreme Court,Donald Trump,Presidential Immunity,Politics,2024 Presidential Election
Question: Could Congress, consistent with the Constitution, enact a statute making it a crime for any person to direct or participate in the use of American military force in the absence of a declaration of war by Congress against the target of that use of force?
Or how about being more direct in targeting the president: Could Congress make it a crime to issue a pardon to a person who has been convicted of conspiring to defraud the United States?
I think the answer to both these questions is no. The Constitution makes the president the commander-in-chief of the armed forces. The Supreme Court has long held, moreover, that a president is not merely authorized but obliged to use whatever force may be necessary to repel an attack, or even a threatened attack, against the United States. Congress may not use its authority to legislate crimes in a manner that encroaches on the president’s authority to direct military operations. And the Constitution vests the president with the pardon power without qualification. This leads to some sticky questions about bribery (an impeachable offense) — i.e., if the president takes a bribe to issue a pardon, may the president be indicted for bribery even if the pardon (probably) may not be invalidated? But bribery aside, Congress may not constitutionally restrict the president’s pardon power by criminalizing its exercise.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Mississippi Releases Bodycam Footage of Police Shooting That Killed 1-Year-Old Kohen Wiley
October 26th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Federal Appeals Court Weighs Trump Administration's Challenge to California Voter Rolls
October 26th, 2026
Recommended Reading
The State of Self-Censorship in the Classroom
AllSides Staff
October 26th, 2026
Recommended Reading
A Suprising Chemistry: The Steven Crowder vs Randall Kennedy Debate
John R. Wood Jr.
October 26th, 2026
More News about Supreme Court
News from the Left
News from the Center
News from the Right
CNBC