As Moore v. Harper Takes Shape, a Broad Coalition Takes Aim at the Independent State Legislature Theory
Federal State And Tribal Powers,Supreme Court,Federalism,Elections
As briefing nears its close, the battle lines are emerging in Moore v. Harper โ the case in which the Supreme Court will consider whether to adopt some form of the independent state legislature (ISL) theory. As a refresher, the ISL theory contends that state legislatures may regulate federal elections free of any checks by other state-level actors. So, under the theory, no state constitutional provisions, no state court, and potentially no governorโs veto could constrain a state legislatureโs exercise of power over federal elections.
In Moore v. Harper, members of the North Carolina state legislature (the petitioners) are invoking the ISL theory to claim that the North Carolina state courts violated the federal constitution when they found congressional maps drawn by the legislature to violate the state constitution. The respondents include the state of North Carolina, as well as the individual voters and non-partisan voting rights and democracy organizations that brought the state court suits challenging the maps. Few significant cases before the Supreme Court in recent memory have seen such a broad coalition from across the political spectrum come together on one side โ in this case, against the independent state legislature theory.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Is Anthropic Losing Its Identity as an AI Safety Leader?
November 20th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Trump Replaces National Cyber Director Amid Questions Over Recent Technology Outages
November 20th, 2026
Recommended Reading
Do Phones Belong in Class?: Understanding the Phone-Free Schools Debate
The Alliance for Civic Engagement
November 20th, 2026
The Insight
Tech Companies, Airlines, National Security Networks: Is the Grid Vulnerable?
AllSides Staff
November 20th, 2026