Trump and Pope Leo Feud Over Iranian War, Role of Religion in Politics

President Trump and Pope Leo XIV's ongoing diplomatic disagreements have intensified as the two leaders traded criticism over the administration's approach to the Iranian war and role of the Pope on political issues.

'Manufacturing Collisions': A Washington Examiner (Lean Right bias) opinion said ongoing tension between the Vatican and the US are due to "fragments of information" that began under Pope Francis, whose "distaste for America…was hardly a secret." It argued that the current feud is a result of "manufacturing collisions" as the media attempts to explain what Pope Leo believes on every issue. It argued against this "mind-reading" of political leaders, saying legacy media should "just tell us what [the pope and the president] said" without "overlay[ing] prior points of view onto the record."

'Messed With The Wrong Pope': An opinion in Vox (Left) outlined Trump's feuds with former Pope Francis and Pope Leo, describing Leo as "a feistier opponent" than the administration may have expected. It outlined Leo's possible advantages, including public support among conservatives and conservative Catholics, him being from the US, and him being seen as "more temperate" in his stances. Fortune (Center) said Trump found someone he "can't intimidate." It described Leo as "a studious and soft-spoken cleric" and Trump as an "unapologetically bellicose and pugilistic politician." It said Trump "sees Leo in terms of nationalistic pride and loyalty," which leads Trump to treat him as a "domestic political rival" due to their disagreements.

Role of The Church: On Tuesday, Vice President JD Vance said Leo should "be careful" when discussing "matters of theology," saying "let the church be the church." NPR (Lean Left) and Fortune both noted popes voicing their opinions on conflicts throughout history. NPR said another reason Leo is speaking out may be the Trump administration's "continued religious rhetoric and imagery." It also said Leo being American could mean greater influence on the perception of US diplomacy. 

In Defense of Religion: Several outlets on the right argued this is a time when the pope would speak out. The National Review Editorial Board (Right) said "Catholics are not required to agree with [Leo]," but that they should take his words "seriously" while "exercising their own judgement" that is "informed by the Gospel." It also described Trump's recent actions as "descend[ing] to something close to deranged buffoonery." An opinion writer in The American Spectator (Right) said while they understand why Trump thinks Leo should get along with him, but Trump was wrong to get angry at the Pope, calling it a "tasteless image" that "underscores the fine line between boldness and blunder." The writer wrote "the pope is right to try to achieve peace by every possible means, and Trump is right to force the end of the ayatollahs' regime."

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission. Suggest an improvement to this summary.