Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 17th, 2023

Death Toll Mounts in Gaza as Israeli-Hamas Fighting Continues

Summary from the AllSides News Team

Voices across the spectrum are reflecting on the mounting death toll in the Gaza Strip resulting from fighting between Israel and Hamas.

“War and Chaos”: Bonnie Kristian (Center bias) drew a distinction between Hamas— an “explicitly antisemitic terrorist group”— and the Palestinian civilians of Gaza, writing, “The millions of Palestinians who live in Gaza—and in Israel, the Palestinian territories, and elsewhere—are not all members or even supporters of Hamas.” Addressing the expected Israeli offensive into Gaza, Kristian warned that “terrorism does not happen in a vacuum” and that terrorist groups “thrive on war and chaos and overbroad revenge projects.”

“Wholesale Destruction”: A writer in Al Jazeera (Lean Left bias) argued that distinctions between Hamas and Palestinians are irrelevant because Israel's true target is the Palestinian people of Gaza. The writer claims that Israeli leadership has been “aching, for a long, frustrating time, to abandon the let’s-teach-Palestinians-a-lethal-lesson spasms of violence in favour of the much more satisfying wholesale destruction of the Gaza Strip.”

“Hamas’ Raison D’etre”: A writer in the Washington Times (Lean Right bias) argued that the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza would end if Hamas surrendered, writing, “Hamas leaders could emerge from the elaborate and expensive tunnels in which they are hiding. They could release their nearly 200 Israeli, American and other hostages.” The writer argues this will not happen because Hamas is not fighting to liberate Palestinians in Gaza, stating, “Hamas’ raison d’etre is killing Jews… Hamas turns metal pipes imported to distribute water into missiles.”

Featured Coverage of this Story

Saving Gazan lives would require only two words: ‘We surrender’
 Saving Gazan lives would require only two words: ‘We surrender’

Alexander Hunter/The Washington Times

Opinion

Much of the media is now moving briskly on from the atrocities committed by Hamas with Tehran’s assistance — the deadliest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust — to the plight of Gazans.

Why must Gazans suffer for the crimes of their leaders, who happen to be designated terrorists?

The answer: They needn’t.

It would require only two words by Hamas leaders to end this war: “We surrender.”

Hamas leaders could emerge from the elaborate and expensive tunnels in which they are hiding. They could release their nearly 200 Israeli,...

Open on Washington Times
This is genocide
This is genocide

Reuters/Mohammed Salem

Opinion

The cataclysm that you and I are witnessing in Gaza is a genocide in the awful making.

It is not an “onslaught”. It is not an “invasion”. It is not even a “war”. It is a genocide.

The apocalyptic scenes and sounds in Gaza are proof that a cruel, occupying army is intent on achieving its overarching aim: the annihilation of what remains of an already shattered slice of land and the indiscriminate killing of helpless, exhausted children, women and men.

Open on Al Jazeera
Blaming Hamas Shouldn't Mean Ignoring the Palestinians' Plight
Blaming Hamas Shouldn't Mean Ignoring the Palestinians' Plight

Abed Rahim Khatib/dpa/picture-alliance/Newscom

Opinion

Who is to blame for the bloodshed in Israel and Gaza?

In one sense, this is a very easy question to answer: Hamas is to blame. This should go without saying, but it has, miserably, become a subject of active conversation thanks to a small but well-placed subset of left-wing activists and students who responded to the initial attack by holding Israel responsible for the violence and loss of life. So let us say it: Hamas is to blame.

Hamas is the explicitly antisemitic terrorist group that began the present...

Open on Bonnie Kristian

More headline roundups

More News about Middle East on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right