Skip to main content

Headline Roundup July 17th, 2024

‘Staged’: Unsubstantiated Theories Spread After Trump Assassination Attempt

Summary from the AllSides News Team

One in five voters find it credible that the attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump was staged, with one in three likely Biden voters agreeing, a Morning Consult poll found. 

Was It Staged? Twelve percent of likely Trump voters also agreed that staging theories were credible. It’s not just an obscure social media trend; Democratic strategist Dmitri Mehlhorn, an adviser to billionaire LinkedIn co-founder and Democratic megadonor Reid Hoffman, apologized on Sunday for suggesting the shooting was staged. Some proponents of the theory cited Trump’s apparent slowness to get to cover, including his request, “Let me get my shoes.” 

Did the Secret Service Intentionally Allow It? The security failings surrounding the shooting have been widely reported, drawing scrutiny towards local police and the Secret Service. But some, including Elon Musk, have suggested that the slowness to stop the shooter was intentional. Some pointed to the vague identity of the shooter, apparently suggesting a broader conspiracy.

How the Media Covered It: Fact checks in mainstream outlets generally dismissed these theories as lacking evidence. Some, however, tied the theories to accusations of irresponsible partisan rhetoric; the Washington Free Beacon (Right bias), for instance, highlighted that Mehlhorn “has visited the Biden White House at least 10 times.”

Watch Out for Misinformation and Unfounded Speculation: As a PolitiFact (Lean Left bias) analysis stated, “Claims that violent incidents and shootings were ‘staged’ are a common trope among misinformers.” Check out our Misinformation Watch page for more. 

Featured Coverage of this Story

From the Center
We fact-checked some of the rumors spreading online about the Trump assassination attempt
We fact-checked some of the rumors spreading online about the Trump assassination attempt

REUTERS/Brendan McDermi/File Photo

Analysis

Misinformation and conspiracy theories were spreading online after an assassination attempt on former U.S. President Donald Trump at a campaign rally on Saturday.

Thomas Matthew Crooks, 20, was alleged to have shot at the Republican presidential candidate from a rooftop during the rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, wounding Trump's right ear. One spectator died and two others were injured.

Reuters has fact-checked some of the most widely shared narratives online.

Within hours of the shooting, an image surfaced, opens new tab online of a man dressed in a black sweatshirt, hat and black sunglasses. Social media posts...

Open on Reuters
From the Left
When Donald Trump was shot, the internet unleashed wild conspiracy theories
When Donald Trump was shot, the internet unleashed wild conspiracy theories

AP

Analysis

The 2024 Republican National Convention opens Monday with the unprecedented and grisly backdrop of its presumptive nominee having survived an assassination attempt. 

Former President Donald Trump arrived for the convention in Wisconsin Sunday, a day after a shooter fired a bullet that Trump said struck him in the upper ear just minutes into a campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania. Authorities say the suspect, Thomas Matthew Crooks, 20, of Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, shot and killed Corey Comperatore, a former volunteer fire chief, and critically injured two more attendees before the Secret...

Open on PolitiFact
From the Right
Dem Powerbroker Who Suggested Trump Shooting ‘Staged’ Has Visited Biden White House at Least 10 Times
Dem Powerbroker Who Suggested Trump Shooting ‘Staged’ Has Visited Biden White House at Least 10 Times

Washington Free Beacon

News

A Democratic powerbroker who pushed the conspiracy theory that the attempted assassination of former president Donald Trump was "staged" has visited the Biden White House at least 10 times, a Washington Free Beacon review of visitor logs found.

Dmitri Mehlhorn has met frequently with aides to White House chief of staff Jeff Zients and Anita Dunn, one of Biden’s closest advisers, according to the logs. Mehlhorn is best known as the political adviser to Democratic megadonor Reid Hoffman, a staunch Trump critic who serves on the Pentagon’s Defense Innovation Board. Hoffman has given $7...

Open on Washington Free Beacon

More headline roundups

More News about Facts and Fact Checking on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right