NYC Mayoral Candidates Face Off in First Debate

The first New York City mayoral debate featured self-proclaimed Democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani, ex-governor Andrew Cuomo running as an Independent, and Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa.

The Details: The debate on Thursday did not bring about any major shift in voter sentiment, according to Lee Miringoff, director of Marist University Institute for Public Opinion. A poll released just before the debate showed Mamdani leading with 52% support from likely voters, with Cuomo and Sliwa trailing at 28% and 14% respectively. Cuomo and Sliwa repeatedly brought up issues surrounding Israel, Mamdani’s past calls to defund the police, and Mamdani’s lack of experience.

For Context: Mamdani, who beat Cuomo in the Democratic primary in June, has been leading in the mayoral race. His core message of "affordability" has resonated with voters, and despite controversy over things like pledging to increase taxes on “richer and whiter neighborhoods,” he remains in the lead. President Donald Trump said that if Mamdani defies current Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) policies once elected, he’ll “have to arrest him.”

How the Media Covered It: The New York Post (Lean Right bias) source panel of political experts concluded that all candidates had strong performances but didn't foresee any major changes in the race before the November 4 election. The article highlighted Mamdani's ability to remain on message and his emphasis on the city's affordability. The experts also noted that Sliwa had a strong performance and commended Cuomo's experience and knowledge of the issues. Newsweek (Center) opened coverage by saying that Mamdani’s odds of winning the 2025 Mayoral race “took a knock” after the televised debate, explaining that after the debate, Betfair dropped the winning percentage from 90% to 88%. Nick Reisman, writing opinion for Politico (Lean Left), called Mamdani “The Front-Runner (Still),” Cuomo “The Has-Been,”  and Sliwa “The Never-Was.” Reisman said Mamdani “was calm, smiled and made his points over attacks” from Cuomo and Sliwa.

Written by the AllSides staff (of humans). Learn more. Support our mission. Suggest an improvement to this summary.