Skip to main content

Headline Roundup October 26th, 2022

Is Targeting Expensive Artwork a Valid Climate Change Protest?

Summary from the AllSides News Team

A recent string of climate protests have targeted acclaimed works of art to draw attention to ongoing ecological damage stemming from fossil fuels. Are they effective, or too outlandish?

For Context: Earlier this month, two individuals affiliated with the climate activist group Just Stop Oil threw cans of tomato soup at the glass casing of Vincent van Gogh’s Sunflowers painting at the London National Gallery. The protest drew major attention, criticism, and discussion on the efficacy of the demonstration and the broader movement of climate activism. The protestors were aware the painting was protected by a glass shield, and it was back on display six hours after the demonstration.

Key Quotes: "What is worth more, art or life?", said one of the protesters. "Is it worth more than food, worth more than justice?"

How the Media Covered It: A writer for Vox argued that the prospect of losing a valuable artwork "allows us to seriously confront the degree to which we as a society collectively dismiss and downplay climate change." Other voices across the spectrum were skeptical or outright critical of the protest, with one Washington Examiner writer stating that "just as some climate skeptics are stuck in climate skepticism bubbles, climate activists are often stuck in alarmist bubbles. Breaking out of these respective groups is crucial if we’re going to make real environmental progress."

Featured Coverage of this Story

Outlandish climate protests are a privilege
Outlandish climate protests are a privilege

AP

Opinion

It’s often said that you’ll catch more flies with honey than vinegar. Climate activists would do well to remember this as they try to build their movement.

Over the last few weeks, activists with Just Stop Oil have been busy with public protests in museums — using everything from soup to pies to mashed potatoes to bring attention to their cause.

If media attention and outrage is the goal, Just Stop Oil is certainly a successful organization. After all, we’re discussing its work right now. But discussion alone is not a...

Open on Washington Examiner
Climate activists divided on souping art
Climate activists divided on souping art

Just Stop Oil / Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

Analysis

From mashed potatoes à la Monet to cake thrown on a wax-imitation of King Charles and tomato soup splashed on a Van Gogh, protesters are targeting famous artworks with food to drum up action on climate change.

Why it matters: The highly publicized protests have spurred conflicting responses across the climate activism community, with some warning that the tactics are counterproductive while others respond with a careful silence.

What they're saying: 18-year-old climate activist Elijah McKenzie-Jackson, campaign coordinator for youth climate strike movement Fridays for Future International, told Axios in...

Open on Axios
How many van Goghs is one Earth worth?
How many van Goghs is one Earth worth?

Stuart C. Wilson/Getty Images

Opinion

“What is worth more, art or life?”

This question — and what would normally be an obvious answer — got a lot more complicated on October 14 when two protesters for the climate activism group Just Stop Oil threw tomato soup on Vincent van Gogh’s Sunflowers at London’s National Gallery. Immediately after the stunt, the protesters challenged onlookers with this query.

“Is it worth more than food? Worth more than justice?” the protester continued. “Are you more concerned about the protection of a painting, or the protection of our planet and people?”

Just...

Open on Vox

More headline roundups

More News about Climate Change on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right