Schumer Introduces Bill to Reverse SCOTUS Presidential Immunity Ruling
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) on Thursday introduced a bill to "clarify" that presidents are not entitled to immunity from criminal prosecution, overturning a precedent established in a Supreme Court decision last month.
Key Details: The "No Kings Act" states that the acts of presidents and vice presidents while in office may be prosecuted for federal crimes, and it would transfer the authority to hear challenges to the legislation's constitutionality from the Supreme Court to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Key Quote: "The Founders were explicit – no man in America shall be a king. Yet, in their disastrous decision, the Supreme Court threw out centuries of precedent and anointed Trump and subsequent presidents as kings above the law," said Schumer. "Congress has an obligation – and a constitutional authority – to act as a check and balance to the judicial branch."
How the Media Covered It: A headline from Fox News (Right bias) said Schumer's bill "advances Biden SCOTUS overhaul," tying the bill to Biden's recently-announced Supreme Court reform plan. The Hill (Center) stated that the bill had "no chance" of passing the 60-vote threshold in the Senate but served as a "protest" from Democrats upset with the Supreme Court decision. NBC News (Lean Left) did not mention that the bill included a transfer of authority from the Supreme Court to the federal court system.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Center
Schumer introduces bill to strip Trump’s presidential immunitySenate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) led 34 Senate Democratic colleagues in introducing legislation to strip former President Trump of the broad immunity from prosecution for official acts the Supreme Court granted him last month.
The Democratic bill, called the “No Kings Act,” would clarify that presidents and vice presidents do not have immunity for acts that violate federal criminal law, and it would remove the Supreme Court’s ability to hear challenges to the constitutionality of the legislation, authorizing the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals instead to hear such challenges.
From the Right
'No Kings Act': Schumer advances Biden SCOTUS overhaul with bill to strip Trump’s immunitySenate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., took the first step to advance President Biden's Supreme Court overhaul plan, beginning with a measure to strip immunity from former President Trump after last month's ruling in his favor. The "No Kings Act" would "clarify" that the Constitution does not entitle presidents to immunity from criminal prosecution for their actions in office, despite the ruling of the high court. In a statement, Schumer reiterated that the Supreme Court's ruling granting former presidents significant immunity for official acts done while in office is "dangerous...
From the Left
Chuck Schumer rolls out ‘No Kings Act’ to eliminate presidential immunityWASHINGTON — Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer on Thursday announced a bill that would ensure that presidents do not have criminal immunity. The legislation is a direct response to the Supreme Court's ruling last month that former President Donald Trump has some immunity for aspects of his presidential conduct. However, even if the bill passes the Senate, it would face an uphill climb in the House, which is controlled by Republican allies of Trump. "Given the dangerous and consequential implications of the Court’s ruling, legislation would be the fastest and...
AllSides Picks
September 9th, 2024
September 9th, 2024