Skip to main content

Headline Roundup December 19th, 2023

Israel’s Accidental Hostage Killing Sparks Discourse on State of Gaza Offensive

Summary from the AllSides News Team

On Friday, the Israeli Defense Forces said it accidentally killed three Israeli hostages in Gaza, sparking media perspectives.

The Zeitgeist: An opinion for Haaretz (Lean Left bias) said what really killed the hostages wasn’t the war, but rather how the current Israeli zeitgeist has desensitized death and dehumanized “non-Jews, Arabs, Palestinians and ‘leftists.’” The writer said that over the past 76 years, Israel has become the “cruelest nation on earth” and that the war's only remaining purpose is to “keep the pile of corpses growing in order to preserve the power of the man who clearly deserves the title of ‘enemy of the state of the Israelis.’”

Rescues Not An Option: A writer for The Jerusalem Post (Center bias) said that “even though shooting under these circumstances runs contrary to the open-fire regulations,” they felt sorry for the soldiers who pulled the triggers. They also said that since Israel has only successfully freed one hostage by military operation so far, anyone who thinks hostages can only be freed like this as opposed to striking deals with Hamas should “reconsider” their stance.

Increased Pressure: An analysis from Washington Times (Lean Right bias) said the hostage killings have “given fuel to critics who say it’s time for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to adjust his approach,” due to the rising number of civilian casualties and lack of a clear metric for victory. It also noted increased pressure from the U.S., which has voiced similar concerns.

Featured Coverage of this Story

From the Right
U.S. pressures Israel after hostage deaths; warships fend off Houthi drones in expanding conflict
U.S. pressures Israel after hostage deaths; warships fend off Houthi drones in expanding conflict

AP Photo/Ariel Schalit

Analysis

Israel faced growing pressure Sunday to scale back its relentless military campaign against Hamas while American warships once again clashed with Iran-backed Houthi rebels in the Red Sea, as the U.S. and its allies raced to contain multiple interconnected conflicts raging across the Middle East.

Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin traveled to Israel over the weekend and privately pressed the government to more precisely define its goals in the Gaza Strip and to offer clear metrics for how and when it can shift to the next phase of the campaign.

Meanwhile, British Foreign Secretary David Cameron and German...

Open on Washington Times
Possible Paywall
From the Center
Heavy feelings following a dark week
Heavy feelings following a dark week

AVSHALOM SASSONI/FLASH90

Opinion

The events involving the IDF in the Shejaia neighborhood in Gaza City, in the second half of last week, leave one with very heavy feelings.

In the first event, which occurred last Tuesday, nine Israeli fighters (several of high military rank) were killed, after four of them got trapped in a building/tunnel complex controlled by Hamas, which they had entered in the course of an operation, and contact with them was lost. Besides concern for the welfare of the four, there was also fear that they might be kidnapped. Successive teams...

Open on The Jerusalem Post
From the Left
Israel's Vigilante Zeitgeist Excuses Any Killing
Israel's Vigilante Zeitgeist Excuses Any Killing

Itai Ron

Opinion

No, it wasn't the tension, or the fear, or the pressure, or even the war that killed the three hostages who tried to save themselves. It was the spirit of the times that killed them. The zeitgeist – a collection of opinions and beliefs and consensus values that characterize a certain society at a certain time. And in the current Israeli zeitgeist, no shortage of evil winds are blowing. A spirit of being easy on the trigger prevails. An unbearable lightness of killing and death. Of dehumanization of non-Jews, Arabs,...

Open on Haaretz
Possible Paywall

More headline roundups

More News about Middle East on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right