Did Glenn Youngkin Allow Police To Search for Women’s Menstrual Histories?
AllSides Summary
Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R) has come under fire for opposing state legislation regarding information on women's menstrual cycles.
The Details: A bill passed by the Virginia state Senate would have prohibited search warrants for obtaining women’s menstrual data on electronic devices. The bill was tabled after opposition from Youngkin’s deputy secretary of public safety, Maggie Cleary. The action has sparked criticism from The Guardian, Washington Post (Lean Left Bias), the Biden Administration, and California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D).
Misleading Claims? The Guardian suggested Youngkin is clearing an “extreme” path for police to be able to search for women’s menstrual histories, something that is already legal in all 50 states. Newsom said Youngkin is “fighting for access to your menstrual cycle information.”
For Context: Although Youngkin has proposed banning abortions after 15 weeks in Virginia, state law currently only allows law enforcement to prosecute doctors, not abortion recipients.
Key Quotes: Cleary said the bill “would be the very first of its kind that I’m aware of, in Virginia or anywhere, that would set a limit on what search warrants can do.” A spokesperson for Youngkin told The Washington Post, "The governor will not support any measures that seek to prosecute women" for abortions.
How The Media Covered It: The Guardian’s original article remains intact, and tweets promoting it remain up. However, Mediaite and Washington Free Beacon both framed The Guardian’s accusations against Youngkin as false, and noted that the outlet stealth-edited its original headline.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Virginia governor blocks bill banning police from seeking menstrual histories

The Republican governor of Virginia, Glenn Youngkin, appears to have thwarted an attempt to stop law enforcement obtaining menstrual histories of women in the state.
A bill passed in the Democratic-led state senate, and supported by half the chamber’s Republicans, would have banned search warrants for menstrual data stored in tracking apps on mobile phones or other electronic devices.
Advocates feared private health information could be used in prosecutions for abortion law violations, after a US supreme court ruling last summer overturned federal protections for the procedure.
But Youngkin, who...
From the Left
The Guardian, Gavin Newsom Falsely Accuse Glenn Youngkin of Special Interest in Menstrual Histories
“Virginia governor clears path for ‘extreme’ bill allowing police to seek menstrual histories.” That false claim about Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin was tweeted out by The Guardian from four separate accounts to a total of 15 million followers this week.
The allegation traveled even further and wider than that, too. Comedienne Samantha Bee declared that she “would love nothing more than to take the Governor of Virginia through my menstrual history in the most vivid detail.” California governor Gavin Newsom mocked Youngkin as “a totally middle of the road guy...
From the Right
FACT CHECK: No, Glenn Youngkin Did Not Empower Police To Seize Women's Menstrual Histories

Claim: Virginia governor Glenn Youngkin (R.) cleared the path for an "extreme" bill "allowing police to seek menstrual histories."
Who said it: The Guardian, in a series of tweets and an article headline that have collectively been viewed nearly 300,000 times.
Why it matters: Since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June, Democrats and liberal media outlets like the Guardian have spread alarm that police may seize data from women's period-tracking apps to target and prosecute women seeking abortions.
Context: A bill passed by the Virginia state Senate...
AllSides Picks

March 17th, 2023

February 27th, 2023


More News about Facts and Fact Checking from the Left, Center and Right
From the Left
From the Center
From the Right














