Skip to main content

Headline Roundup May 4th, 2023

Trump Lawsuit Against New York Times Dismissed

Summary from the AllSides News Team

On Wednesday, a New York Supreme Court Judge dismissed former President Donald Trump's $100 million lawsuit against the New York Times, and ordered Trump to pay all legal fees.

Key Details: The judge has ruled that the newspaper reporting on Trump's tax returns, which won a Pulitzer Prize, was protected by the First Amendment. The New York Times raised questions about Trump's claim to be a self-made millionaire, and alleged that Trump was involved in questionable tax schemes. Trump accused the paper of an "insidious plot" to illegally obtain copies of his confidential tax documents.

Key Quote: "The New York Times is pleased with the judge's decision today. It is an important precedent reaffirming that the press is protected when it engages in routine newsgathering to obtain information of vital importance to the public," said NYT spokesperson Charlie Stadtlander in an emailed statement.

For Context: Trump filed his suit against the New York Times in 2021 for the reporting, and the suit also accused Trump's niece, Mary Trump, of a plot to obtain his tax records. The judge has not reached a decision regarding that claim.

How the Media Covered it: Some left-rated sources reported that Trump's attorneys might appeal the ruling.

Featured Coverage of this Story

Judge dismisses Trump's lawsuit against the New York Times
Judge dismisses Trump's lawsuit against the New York Times

Getty Images

News

A judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by former US President Donald Trump against the New York Times.

The $100m (ÂŁ79m) lawsuit accused the newspaper and Mr Trump's estranged niece, Mary Trump, of "an insidious plot" to obtain his tax records.

It was filed in 2021 and relates to a Pulitzer Prize-winning series on Mr Trump's financial affairs.

On Wednesday, Judge Robert Reed said the claims in the lawsuit "fail as a matter of constitutional law".

"Courts have long recognised that reporters are entitled to engage in legal and ordinary...

Open on BBC News
Judge Dismisses Trump's Lawsuit Vs. NY Times
News

A New York Supreme Court judge on Wednesday dismissed former President Donald Trump's lawsuit against The New York Times.

According to Axios, the former president filed his $100 million lawsuit against the newspaper and his niece Mary Trump in 2021 over The Times' 2018 reporting of his tax records. Trump has since alleged that it was "an insidious plot to obtain confidential and highly sensitive records."

But Judge Robert Reed said Trump's allegations "fail as a matter of constitutional law."

Courts have "long recognized," Reed said, "that reporters are entitled to...

Open on Newsmax (News)
Judge Dismisses Trump’s Suit Against New York Times, Orders Him To Pay Legal Fees
News

A New York judge dismissed former President Donald Trump’s lawsuit against The New York Times on Wednesday, saying the newspaper’s reporting on his tax returns was protected by the First Amendment.

Trump sued the paper, three of its reporters and his niece Mary Trump in 2021 after a series of bombshell reports about his tax records. The former president demanded “no less” than $100 million at the time, accusing the journalists of taking part in an “insidious plot” to obtain the records from his niece.

The series later won a Pulitzer Prize.

The judge rejected the former president’s...

Open on HuffPost

More headline roundups

More News about Donald Trump on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right