Skip to main content

Headline Roundup July 16th, 2024

Secret Service, Law Enforcement Under Scrutiny for Shooter Response at Trump Rally

Summary from the AllSides News Team

New details about last weekend’s shooting at a Trump rally were reported on Monday by Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle and Butler County Sheriff Michael Slupe, intensifying scrutiny of their respective organizations and their leadership.

Key Details: Cheatle told ABC News (Lean Left bias):

  • The Secret Service was aware that the building was a security vulnerability, but decided to station officers inside the building only since the slope of the roof was a “safety factor” for officers.
  • A local police officer noticed Crooks carrying a rangefinder and alerted colleagues 30 minutes before the shooting.

Slupe told Pittsburgh’s KDKA-TV (Not Rated):

  • While one local officer was pulling himself onto the roof by his arms, Crooks turned his rifle on the officer, who let go and fell to the ground.

Key Quote: "I would have done the same thing, absolutely," Sheriff Slupe said. "I mean, people think the officers are supermen like you hold on the roof with one hand while you are hanging on for dear life and pull a gun out. It doesn't work that way."

How the Media Covered It: Sources across the spectrum were critical of the Secret Service and local law enforcement. New York Post (Lean Right) wrote an article alleging that First Lady Jill Biden had personally advocated for Cheatle’s appointment. Many Right-biased outlets wrote Cheatle’s first name as “Kim,” an informal-sounding nickname that could convey incompetence; outlets on the left called her “Kimberly.”

Featured Coverage of this Story

What to know about the head of Secret Service as agency faces scrutiny
What to know about the head of Secret Service as agency faces scrutiny

Morry Gash/AP

News

The U.S. Secret Service is at the center of questions about security after a shooting at a rally for former president Donald Trump in Butler, Pa. The agency, under the Department of Homeland Security, is charged with safeguarding the president, vice president and other top U.S. and foreign dignitaries.

Kimberly Cheatle is the 27th director of the U.S. Secret Service; she was sworn into office on Sept. 17, 2022. She oversees more than 7,800 special agents, uniformed officers and other personnel, according to the agency. She is also a former agent who served more...

Open on Washington Post
Trump Shooting Thrusts Role of Local Authorities Into Spotlight
Trump Shooting Thrusts Role of Local Authorities Into Spotlight

Evan Vucci/AP

News

From his second-row seat at Donald Trump’s Pennsylvania campaign rally on Saturday, Butler County Sheriff Michael Slupe heard a “bam-bam-bam” as the former president was speaking, and at first he thought about a complaint lodged earlier in the day about fireworks near the site.

Slupe said he learned later that a local police officer spotted gunman Thomas Matthew Crooks before he opened fire but was unable to stop him. The officer was helped by a colleague onto the roof where Crooks was positioned, but when Crooks turned toward him, the officer dropped to the ground, Slupe said.

Open on Wall Street Journal (News)
Secret Service Director Kim Cheatle landed job after push by Jill Biden’s office, sources say
Secret Service Director Kim Cheatle landed job after push by Jill Biden’s office, sources say

Reuters

News

Embattled Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle, who is facing congressional outcry and calls to resign over security lapses leading to former President Donald Trump’s near-assassination Saturday, landed her role thanks largely to a close relationship with first lady Jill Biden, The Post has learned.

Cheatle, 53, is the second woman to lead the presidential protection agency and secured the non-Senate-confirmed role in August 2022 after a three-year stint as senior director of global security at PepsiCo.

Before that, she had served 27 years in the Secret Service, beginning in the Clinton administration.

...
Open on New York Post (News)

More headline roundups

More News about Donald Trump on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right