It is already politicizing charitable organizations. It may also destroy them.
For people who are worried about whether a new woke ideology has taken over philanthropy, there is good news and bad news. The bad news is that it is everywhere. From the biggest foundations to the smallest nonprofits, an agenda of racial equity and identity politics is pervasive. The good news, though, is that this ideology is so divorced from reality that it might spell the end of many of these organizations.
Over the past year, billions of dollars have been pledged to support the cause of racial equity. According to a report from the AP, $12 billion in charitable contributions were βearmarked for racial equityβ in the past year. A recent survey from the Center for Effective Philanthropy of 800 foundations found that 75 percent βhad initiated efforts to support nonprofits that serve communities of color.β And according to Ellie Buteau, the Center for Effective Philanthropyβs vice president of research, the foundations were βtrying to learn more about racismβ and βself-reflectβ about hiring and grant-making.
Indeed, for many foundations, the new mandate is not simply to give to more woke causes, regardless of their organizationβs mission. It is to entirely change the way they do business. A recent article in the Chronicle of Philanthropy advised foundations that βto decolonize philanthropy, we need to create diversity in fundraising.β The author noted that βRight now, raising money is designed to approach and engage old, straight white men β especially in major-gift fundraising. . . . If we are running a childrenβs health organization in Atlanta, for example, then we should have African American major donors, not just old white people, and the number of women donors should reflect the community.β
Of course, if you think that old straight white men are the ones with a disproportionate share of the money, it would probably make sense for your nonprofit to focus on asking them for some. But now it seems that optics matter more than financial resources for, say, childrenβs health in Atlanta.