Was the media biased in its coverage of both stories? Drew Holden, a freelance commentary writer not yet rated by AllSides, says it was. He tracked media coverage of both stories and claimed media bias in a Twitter thread.
It should be noted that Holden primarily highlights coverage from media outlets rated Left, Lean Left, or Center by AllSides: CNN (Left), The New York Times (Lean Left), MSNBC (Left), TIME (Lean Left), The Washington Post (Lean Left), NPR (Center), PBS News House (Center), and ABC News (Lean Left). AllSides has not analyzed right-wing media on this issue, so bias from that side of the spectrum on this story may be missing. Still, we found this thread worth sharing with our readers to help you learn how to spot media bias.
The most common type of media bias that Holden caught here is slant, which is when journalists tell only part of a story, or when they highlight, focus on, or play up one particular angle or piece of information. It can include cherry-picking information or data to support one side, or ignoring another perspective. Slant prevents readers from getting the full story, and narrows the scope of our understanding.
Did you spot any right-wing media bias on this topic? Is this a fair analysis, or the wrong comparison to draw? An AllSides team member with a Lean Left bias said the Trump and Biden troop withdrawals were substantively different, which should complicate any effort to compare the two. What do you think? Give us feedback.
Update 4/21/2021 12:28 pm EST: An AllSides team member found a number of articles from left-wing media outlets that published takes critical of Biden's withdrawal. Does the presence of these articles change your overall perception of how Left- and Center-rated media covered the story? Some articles: Afghans who worked for US plea for help after Biden announces exit (ABC News), Concerns mount that US withdrawal from Afghanistan could risk progress on women's rights (CNN), Afghanistan withdrawal will likely dismantle a CIA intelligence network built up over 20 years Afghanistan withdrawal will likely dismantle a CIA intelligence network built up over 20 years (CNN).
When Trump said we were leaving, @CNN quoted the NATO Sec Gen with a “stark warning” about how “dangerous” the move would be.— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) April 14, 2021
But Biden’s decision? Well, on that one, we just get to hear from his people. pic.twitter.com/b8KHDPNrmN
Starting to see it? pic.twitter.com/Qryo6ZU9je— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) April 14, 2021
For Trump, we hear about the “fears” of Afghan officials from @nytimes.— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) April 14, 2021
Biden, on the other hand, gets a sympathetic write up despite being the second most powerful man in the country during the height of US forces. Just incredible memoryholing here. pic.twitter.com/2vu2GdBqxR
Julie Mastrine is the Director of Marketing at AllSides. She has a Lean Right bias.