Will the Supreme Court Rule Trump Has Presidential Immunity?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
Will the Supreme Court agree that former President Donald Trump has presidential immunity from his federal charges?
For Context: On Wednesday, the Supreme Court agreed to hear arguments regarding Trump’s claim that he has presidential immunity from the federal charges he faces pertaining to the 2020 election. The court is expected to hear arguments in late April.
How Will They Rule? Across the spectrum, outlets are predicting that the Justices rule against Trump and deny his immunity argument. Newsweek (Center bias) quoted Greg Germain, a law professor at Syracuse University in New York, stating, “It's an interesting legal issue when phrased in the abstract, because a president should certainly be immune from criminal prosecution for some core official acts, but not for acts done for personal gain or unconnected with the president's official duties. The president should be immune from wartime decisions, for example.”
How Will It Impact the DOJ Case? Until the Supreme Court hears arguments and issues a ruling, the Justice Department’s case against Trump is halted. The trial was slated to begin in March, but it will most likely be delayed until at least the summer, assuming the Justices do not rule that Trump has immunity from the charges. Some outlets are speculating that the delay will push the trial past the November presidential election.
How the Media Covered It: Outlets across the spectrum deemed this development a win for Trump, determining that his strategy in his legal proceedings has been to delay past the election.
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
A landmark case? Takeaways from Trump's immunity claim at Supreme CourtFormer President Donald Trump welcomed the Supreme Court’s decision to hear his argument for immunity from federal charges he tried to steal the 2020 election, but legal experts feared a broad protection from prosecution after leaving office could turn presidents into dictators.
The high court’s decision to hear the landmark case in April will delay the high-profile criminal trial for months. It's unclear whether the delay will push the trial beyond the November election.
Trump has repeatedly claimed that the charges are politically motivated. If he returns to the White...
From the Center
Supreme Court Decision Might Not Help Donald Trump After AllThe U.S. Supreme Court is unlikely to grant Donald Trump immunity from prosecution, legal experts have said.
On Wednesday, the Supreme Court agreed to hear Trump's claim that he has presidential immunity from his election fraud trial in Washington D.C.
Regardless of the outcome, the Supreme Court has helped Trump's goal of delaying the case until after the 2024 presidential election.
If elected president, Trump has several options to end the trial, including pardoning himself or appointing a favorable attorney general to drop the case.
If the Supreme Court takes...
From the Right
Supreme Court Will Review Trump’s Immunity ClaimThe United States Supreme Court will review former president Donald Trump’s claim that he is immune from criminal prosecution. The Court announced its decision this afternoon.
It is expected that the Court will schedule the immunity case for argument in late April — probably the week of April 22. That makes it likely that the justices will decide the case in late June.
This makes the prospect of a trial prior to Election Day of Biden Justice Department special counsel Jack Smith’s 2020 election-interference charges against Trump more remote —...
AllSides Picks
June 14th, 2024
June 11th, 2024
June 14th, 2024
June 14th, 2024
Discuss & Debate polarization
Cybersecurity: Keeping Our Country Safe?
June 16 at 5pm PT / 8pm ET Crossing Party Lines