What Will SCOTUS Reversal of Colorado Trump Ruling Mean for the Election?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
What does the Supreme Court’s decision to reinstate Republican frontrunner and former President Donald Trump on the Colorado ballot mean for the 2024 election and Trump’s other legal cases?
“Another January 6”: Dan McLaughlin (Right bias) determined the justices were correct to overturn the Colorado ruling, but they “shirked their duty to finally adjudicate whether Trump is covered by Section 3 and whether he engaged in insurrection.” In leaving this matter unaddressed, McLaughlin concluded, “the likeliest outcome is now that any challenge to Trump’s qualification will be made in Congress after the election, when the electoral votes are counted. Such an effort could bring us full circle to another January 6.”
Not a “Home Run” For Trump: An article in Newsweek (Center bias) quoted legal scholars concluding that the ruling was not a complete victory for Trump, stating, “it failed to do what the former president had asked—clear him of insurrection—and because of this, it could signal bad news down the road.”
“The Cavalry Isn’t Coming”: A writer in the Daily Beast (Left bias) determined Democrats supporting Trump’s removal from the ballot didn’t “think through the political implications.” Had the Supreme Court upheld the Colorado ruling, “Democrats would have to again deal with the false narrative that they tipped the scales in an election.” With the ballot access issue settled, the writer urges Democrats to accept that “The cavalry isn’t coming to save us from the scourge of another Trump presidency, only we can save our nation.”
Featured Coverage of this Story
From the Left
Forget the Supreme Court, Beat Trump at the BallotThe Supreme Court, in a unanimous decision, ruled today that former President Donald Trump can appear on the ballot in Colorado for the upcoming presidential election.
The decision came after six Colorado voters filed a lawsuit against Trump and the Colorado secretary of state, arguing that when Trump on Jan. 6 led an insurrection to breach the Capitol as Congress certified the 2020 election results, he was constitutionally ineligible to serve as president again because of Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment.
Section 3, in summation, states that an elected...
From the Center
Supreme Court's Ballot Ruling Wasn't a Home Run for Donald TrumpThe Supreme Court handed former President Donald Trump's 2024 campaign a win with its latest ruling, but it wasn't exactly a home run for the Republican frontrunner.
The court ruled in Trump's favor Monday, reversing the Colorado Supreme Court's decision that determined the former president was ineligible for the state's primary ballot because of his role in the January 6, 2021, Capitol Riot. In a unanimous ruling, the nine justices agreed that an individual state shouldn't be able to choose who gets to run for the White House.
However, the...
From the Right
Haste and Acrimony Undermine a Unanimous Supreme Court in Trump-Eligibility CaseThe Supreme Court this morning put an end to court challenges to Donald Trump’s qualification for the presidency under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. It did so the day before the Super Tuesday primaries in Colorado and Maine, two states that have sought to bar Trump from the ballot. Not one justice thought that Colorado had the power to do what it did in a decision full of elastic reasoning. Only the most deluded figures of the legal “Resistance” ever believed this gambit would work.
The Court was right...
AllSides Picks
June 14th, 2024
June 11th, 2024
June 14th, 2024
June 14th, 2024