Headline Roundup June 14, 2024
Was the Supreme Court Right to Overturn the Bump Stock Ban?
Summary from the AllSides News Team
On Friday, the Supreme Court overruled a federal ban on bump stocks. The ruling renewed debate across the political spectrum over the controversial firearm modification.
From the Left: A writer in Salon (Left bias) stated, โOne might hope a ruling that stands to inflict so much carnage would, at least, be indisputably compelled by law. It is not,โ arguing that the ruling โtortures statutory text beyond all recognition, defying Congressโ clear and (until now) well-established commands.โ The writer argued the court misrepresented and unfairly dismissed investigations conducted by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives on bump stocks that deemed semi-automatic weapons equipped with bump stocks to be classified as machine guns, which strengthened the legal case for a ban.
From the Right: Charles C. W. Cooke (Right bias) argued the case โwas not whether bump stocks count as โarms,โ but whether the National Firearms Act of 1934 grants the executive branch the power to regulate them in the same manner as it regulates machine guns. As the Court makes clear, the answer to this is unquestionably no. In consequence, the regulation must fall.โ Cooke determined the ban only happened as a result of the 2018 Las Vegas shooting, stating, โThat pressure was real. But it was not law.โ Cooke concluded, โIf one wishes, one can argue that Congress ought to have changed the law after the Nevada massacre. But it didnโt. And, because it didnโt, the executive branchโ did not have the power to do so.
Featured Coverage of this Story

Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by Ethan Miller/Getty Images, Olivier Douliery/AFP via Getty Images, George Frey/Getty Images, and supremecourt.gov.
The Supreme Courtโs conservative supermajority carved a huge loophole into the federal prohibition against machine guns on Friday, striking down a bump stock ban first enacted in 2018 by the Trump administration. Its 6โ3 decision allows civilians to convert AR-15โstyle rifles into automatic weapons that can fire at a rate of 400โ800 rounds per minute. One might hope a ruling that stands to inflict so much carnage would, at least, be indisputably compelled by law. It is not. Far from it: To reach this result, Justice Clarence Thomasโ opinion for...
The Supreme Courtโs decision invalidating the nationwide bump stock ban ignited a firestorm among Democrats and gun control groups that have long maligned the device used to perpetrate the nationโs deadliest mass shooting.
The groups expressed worry about not only the impacts of lifting the ban, which could trigger a booming rapid-fire marketplace, but also the other gun cases that remain pending on the justicesโ docket.
Republicans and gun-rights groups like the National Rifle Association (NRA), meanwhile, celebrated Fridayโs decision as a necessary pull-back on firearm restrictions and executive-branch overreach.
...

George Grey/Reuters
The Supreme Court has struck down the reclassification of bump stocks that was promulgated by the Trump administration back in 2018. As I noted earlier this year, this was not a Second Amendment case, but a statutory case, and, as such, the question was not whether bump stocks count as โarms,โ but whether the National Firearms Act of 1934 grants the executive branch the power to regulate them in the same manner as it regulates machine guns. As the Court makes clear, the answer to this is unquestionably no. In...
AllSides Picks
Headline Roundup
Trump Admin Proposes Selling Federal Public Lands, Draws Bipartisan Pushback
November 18th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Hakeem Jeffries Wins Democratic Nomination for Speaker of the House
November 18th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Pentagon Fails Ninth Annual Audit in a Row, Sparks Bipartisan Media Criticism
November 18th, 2026
Blog
Tracking Trumpโs Campaign Promises
AllSides Staff
November 18th, 2026
More News about Supreme Court on AllSides
News from the Left
News from the Center
News from the Right
CNBC