Skip to main content

Headline Roundup February 10th, 2021

Biden Administration Tells Supreme Court It Thinks ACA Is Constitutional

Summary from the AllSides News Team

The Biden administration told the Supreme Court it considers the Affordable Care Act (ACA) constitutional, reversing the Trump administration's position on the healthcare law. A Justice Department lawyer sent a letter to the court on Wednesday changing the government’s position in a case called California v. Texas, which was argued last November; a decision has yet to be announced. In November, Trump, along with several other Republican-led states, argued that the ACA (also known as Obamacare) was unconstitutional because its individual mandate, a tax which propped up the law’s constitutionality in past cases, was removed by Congress in 2017. They argued that the individual mandate was essential to the ACA and that the ACA must fall as a result. As vice president under the Obama administration, Biden played a key role in passing the legislation through Congress in 2010. The story received wide coverage from across the political spectrum. Coverage from the left and the center tended to focus on the details of the case; some right-rated outlets also highlighted reactions from Republican lawmakers and attempted to predict the outcome of the case.

Featured Coverage of this Story

Justice Department tells Supreme Court it thinks Obamacare is constitutional, reversing Trump-era position
Justice Department tells Supreme Court it thinks Obamacare is constitutional, reversing Trump-era position

CNBC

News

The Department of Justice notified the Supreme Court on Wednesday that it no longer considers Obamacare to be unconstitutional, the latest reversal from the department since President Joe Biden was inaugurated in January.

The Supreme Court is considering a challenge to Obamacare, formally known as the Affordable Care Act, brought by Texas and other Republican-led states. The Justice Department under former President Donald Trump backed Texas in legal briefs and during oral arguments in November.

California and other blue states are defending the law, under which 20 million Americans have...

Open on CNBC
Biden administration tells Supreme Court Obamacare is constitutional, should be saved
Biden administration tells Supreme Court Obamacare is constitutional, should be saved

Washington Post

News

President Biden’s administration told the Supreme Court on Wednesday that his predecessor had been wrong to argue that the Affordable Care Act was unconstitutional and urged the court to uphold the health-care law.

A top Justice Department lawyer, in a letter to the court, reversed the government’s position in a case argued last November and in which a decision has not been announced. While it is rare for the government to switch its position in a case, this change was expected, and this case could be the first of several...

Open on Washington Post
Biden kills federal government's Supreme Court challenge to Obamacare
Biden kills federal government's Supreme Court challenge to Obamacare

Washington Examiner

News

President Biden on Wednesday changed the federal government's position in a Supreme Court case where former President Donald Trump challenged the Affordable Care Act's constitutionality.

The case, California v. Texas, was argued a week after the 2020 election. Many legal experts predicted that Biden would drop the government's offense on the act soon after he took office. In a letter to the court, Deputy Solicitor General Edwin Kneedler wrote that the Biden’s Justice Department "reconsidered" the facts of the case and now opposes Trump’s position.

The switch comes after Trump,...

Open on Washington Examiner

More headline roundups

More News about Public Health on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right