Skip to main content

Headline Roundup November 13th, 2024

Trump Team Drafted Executive Order to Create Board to Fast-Track Removal of Generals

Summary from the AllSides News Team

The Wall Street Journal (Center bias) reported on an executive order drafted by President-elect Trump's transition team that would establish a “warrior board” of retired military personnel with the power to recommend the removal of three and four-star generals. 

The Order: The order said it aims to review officers "on leadership capability, strategic readiness, and commitment to military excellence," though specific standards aren't named. The Wall Street Journal said, "As commander in chief, Trump can fire any officer at will, but an outside board whose members he appoints would bypass the Pentagon’s regular promotion system, signaling across the military that he intends to purge a number of generals and admirals." Adding, "The warrior board would be made up of retired generals and noncommissioned officers, who would send their recommendations to the president. Those identified for removal would be retired at their current rank within 30 days."

For Context: On the campaign trial, Trump said he would fire "woke generals." If signed, the order would fulfill that promise. 

How the Media Covered It: The Daily Beast (Left bias) framed it as a way for Trump to fire any generals he doesn't like, while a National Review (Right bias) writer said he fears returning to reporting practices "in which every proposed action by a Trump administration is written as a tectonic, norms-defying event without precedent or historic rationale. But the act of removing bad or distracted leaders is a tool as old as war itself."

Featured Coverage of this Story

Trump Plans Squad to Fire the Generals He Hates
Trump Plans Squad to Fire the Generals He Hates

Mark Wilson/Getty Images

News

President-elect Donald Trump’s transition team is looking at ways to make good on his promise to purge the military of “woke” generals—including a draft executive order that would create a “warrior board” to review the conduct of officials and recommend names for firing, according to a Wall Street Journal report.

The board, which would consist of retired senior military officials, would have the power to recommend the dismissal of any three- or four-star generals that are deemed “lacking in requisite leadership qualities,” a draft of the executive order obtained by the Journal reads.

Open on Daily Beast
Trump Prepares a Pentagon Plucking Committee
Trump Prepares a Pentagon Plucking Committee

Joshua Roberts/Reuters

Analysis

The Wall Street Journal reported today that the Trump transition team is drafting an executive order to “create a board to purge general officers.” Such a board, the article’s subhead warned, “could upend military review process and raise concerns about politicization of military.”

To the first suggestion, on upending the military review process, you will find no shortage of active-duty service members who say, “Hell to the yes.”

Open on National Review (Opinion)
Trump Draft Executive Order Would Create Board to Purge Generals
Trump Draft Executive Order Would Create Board to Purge Generals

Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call/Zuma Press

News

The Trump transition team is considering a draft executive order that establishes a “warrior board” of retired senior military personnel with the power to review three- and four-star officers and to recommend removals of any deemed unfit for leadership.

If Donald Trump approves the order, it could fast-track the removal of generals and admirals found to be “lacking in requisite leadership qualities,” according to a draft of the order reviewed by The Wall Street Journal. But it could also create a chilling effect on top military officers, given the president-elect’s past vow to fire...

Open on Wall Street Journal (News)

More headline roundups

More News about Donald Trump on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right