Skip to main content

Headline Roundup June 15th, 2023

Judge in Trump Classified Docs Case Accused of Pro-Trump Bias

Summary from the AllSides News Team

Left-rated voices are expressing fear that Federal Judge Eileen Cannon— the judge assigned the Department of Justice’s case against former President Donald Trump— is biased toward Trump, who nominated her to be a federal judge in 2020. 

For Context: Cannon also presided over the legal battle following the Mar-a-Lago raid in August, when FBI agents executed a warrant search of Trump’s Florida residence, seizing over 100 documents with classified markings. Cannon was criticized during this legal proceeding for granting a motion from the Trump team to appoint a “special master” to review the seized documents and remove any materials protected by “executive privilege,” pausing the FBI’s investigation into the documents in a move The Hill (Center bias) deemed “extraordinary.” This decision was later appealed and overturned, with an appeals court ruling that despite unprecedented circumstances, the judiciary did not have “license to interfere in an ongoing investigation.”

From the Left: A Politico (Lean Left bias) analysis stated Trump won the “judicial lottery” having Cannon as his judge. Breaking down the power Cannon has in determining the speed, direction, and potential sentencing of the trial, the article determines she will hold “an even more powerful position to steer Trump’s legal fortunes.”

From the Right: A Townhall (Right bias) analysis outlined the criticism from left-rated voices, from her “presumed Republican” affiliation to her background as a member of the Federalist Society, a conservative legal organization. The article determined that Democrats are worried Cannon “could blow the Left's whole plan of destroying Trump.”

Featured Coverage of this Story

Why the Judge Who May Preside Over Trump’s Case Is Angering Democrats
Why the Judge Who May Preside Over Trump’s Case Is Angering Democrats

AP Photo/Seth Wenig

Analysis

Democrats are angered by the fact that a Trump-appointed judge may preside over the former President's case. 

Florida judge Aileen Cannon is facing heat for being listed on the summons for Trump's Tuesday Miami appearance to face charges in federal court. 

Democrats are reportedly worried that Cannon can blow the whole case since past rulings from her have slowed the Department of Justice's investigation into Trump— which she banned prosecutors from using the classified documents they seized from his Mar-a-Lago home. 

Open on Townhall
Trump-appointed judge Aileen Cannon assigned to his documents case
Trump-appointed judge Aileen Cannon assigned to his documents case

The Hill

News

Judge Aileen Cannon, a Trump appointee who took the extraordinary step of appointing a special master in the Mar-a-Lago case, may initially oversee the case, according to reporting from multiple outlets.

Cannon’s name appeared on the summons for Donald Trump’s Tuesday appearance, as did Judge Bruce Reinhart, who approved the warrant to search the former president’s Florida home, ABC News first reported Friday.

Rulings from Cannon substantially slowed the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) investigation into Trump, in one instance barring prosecutors from using the classified documents they seized from the home.

Open on The Hill
Trump drew one of his favorite judges. Here’s how she could help his case.
 Trump drew one of his favorite judges. Here’s how she could help his case.

Win McNamee/Getty Images

Analysis

Donald Trump seemed to win the judicial lottery when his newest criminal case — a 37-count indictment for hoarding classified documents and obstructing a grand jury probe — landed before U.S. District Court Judge Aileen Cannon.

Cannon, a Trump appointee confirmed to the federal bench just days after Trump lost his reelection bid, ruled deferentially for Trump last summer when he contested the FBI’s seizure of some of those very documents. Legal experts described Cannon’s pro-Trump rulings at the time as audacious and even lawless, and a conservative appeals-court panel...

Open on Politico

More headline roundups

More News about Donald Trump on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right