Skip to main content

Headline Roundup September 11th, 2020

Controversial Study Estimates "Superspreader" Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Linked to 266,000 COVID-19 Cases

Summary from the AllSides News Team

A study from San Diego State University and the IZA Institute of Labor Economics suggests that last month’s Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, which drew over 460,000 attendees to South Dakota, was a "superspreader" event potentially linked to 266,000 COVID-19 cases around the country. The Sturgis rally drew criticism in August due to health experts’ warnings against large gatherings. The study has received some criticism in peer reviews and strong pushback from some public officials. The researchers stand by their work, which was based on county-level data and anonymized cellphone tracking data. Many reports from right-rated outlets focused on researchers and public officials’ criticisms of the study. Coverage in some left-rated outlets discussed scientific criticisms of the study, and coverage in other left-rated outlets only discussed criticisms of the study towards the end of articles. Editor's Note: This story's headline has been updated to include the word "controversial". Updated 9/11/20 at 8:34 p.m. ET

Featured Coverage of this Story

The Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Was A Massive COVID-19 Superspreader Event, A New Study Claims
The Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Was A Massive COVID-19 Superspreader Event, A New Study Claims

BuzzFeed News

News

The massive Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, which brought more than 460,000 people to a tiny city of 7,000 residents in South Dakota in August, was a “superspreader” event that was responsible for more than 260,000 new cases of COVID-19 across the nation.

That’s the provocative conclusion from a new study from the Center for Health Economics & Policy Studies at San Diego State University, which also estimated that these cases cost the nation around $12.2 billion.

These numbers have been rejected by city and state officials, who noted that the study...

Open on BuzzFeed News
Was Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Responsible for 250K Coronavirus Cases?
Was Sturgis Motorcycle Rally Responsible for 250K Coronavirus Cases?

Snopes

Fact Check

In September 2020, social media was abuzz over a report from the IZA Institute of Labor Economics that linked 266,796 COVID-19 coronavirus cases (a figure that was reported as “more than 250,000” in various headlines) to the Sturgis motorcycle rally held in Sturgis, South Dakota:

IZA Institute of Labor Economics truly did publish a paper estimating that the rally was linked to a surge of approximately 250,000 COVID-19 cases (representing a cost of $12.2 billion). However, while the rally likely contributed to a rise in coronavirus cases, the figures stated...

Open on Snopes
South Dakota governor calls Sturgis ‘superspreading’ study ‘completely untrue’
South Dakota governor calls Sturgis ‘superspreading’ study ‘completely untrue’

New York Post (News)

News

South Dakota’s Gov. Kristi Noem has continued her attack on a recent study that argued the massive Sturgis motorcycle rally was a COVID-19 “superspreading” event linked to almost 20 percent of new cases nationwide last month — calling it “back of the napkin math” and “completely untrue.”

Some 300 attendees from 12 states have tested positive for coronavirus after attending the rally, including at least one who died.

And while it’s unclear how many people those infected attendees then spread the virus to, South Dakota saw a 35 percent post-rally...

Open on New York Post (News)

More headline roundups

More News about Coronavirus on AllSides

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right