America has two types of exceptionalist. One believes the US is a unique force for good in the world. The other blames the world's ills on America. What they share is incuriosity about non-Americans. Whether light or dark, only America has agency. The light version has been badly discredited by wars of choice in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere. Negative exceptionalists have thus been on the rise. Their long-held expectation of Russia's victory over Ukraine is starting to look possible.
Though he follows neither school, President Donald Trump's ending of what remains of US support for Ukraine makes him the dark exceptionalists' harbinger. Those applauding his pro-Russia tilt come from the Maga right and what used to be called the tankie left. During the cold war, American tankies saw the Soviet Union as the anti-imperialist bulwark against a rogue America. Like Tucker Carlson from the right, today they seek to explain Vladimir Putin.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
News
Tracking Trump’s Campaign Promises
AllSides Staff
November 18th, 2026
Story of the Week
Are Putin and Zelenskyy Ready for Peace?
AllSides Staff
October 22nd, 2026
Headline Roundup
Is Anthropic Losing Its Identity as an AI Safety Leader?
November 20th, 2026
Headline Roundup
Trump Replaces National Cyber Director Amid Questions Over Recent Technology Outages
November 20th, 2026