A Dangerous Court Order Against The New York Times
Media Industry,Free Speech,Freedom Of The Press,New York Times Bias,Project Veritas,Media Bias,1st Amendment
Half a century ago, the Supreme Court settled the matter of when a court can stop a newspaper from publishing. In 1971, the Nixon administration attempted to block The Times and The Washington Post from publishing classified Defense Department documents detailing the history of the Vietnam War β the so-called Pentagon Papers. Faced with an asserted threat to the nationβs security, the Supreme Court sided with the newspapers. βWithout an informed and free press, there cannot be an enlightened people,β Justice Potter Stewart wrote in a concurring opinion.
That sentiment reflects one of the oldest and most enduring principles in our legal system: The government may not tell the press what it can and cannot publish. This principle long predates the Constitution, but so there would be no mistake, the nationβs founders included a safeguard in the Bill of Rights anyway. The First Amendment says, βCongress shall make no law β¦ abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.β
This is why virtually every official attempt to bar speech or news reporting in advance, known as a prior restraint, gets struck down. βAny system of prior restraints of expression comes to this court bearing a heavy presumption against its constitutional validity,β the Supreme Court said in a 1963 case. Such restraints are βthe very prototype of the greatest threat to First Amendment values,β Justice Antonin Scalia wrote a generation later.
Related Coverage
AllSides Picks
Announcement
Why AllSides Uses the Term βAssisted Dyingβ and Not βAssisted Suicideβ
AllSides Staff
October 31st, 2026
Red Blue Translator
Media Elite
Red Blue Translator
Liberal Media
Headline Roundup
Fuel Prices Fall After Midterms, Prompting Debate Over What Drove the Decline
November 19th, 2026