Skip to main content

A Dangerous Court Order Against The New York Times

Media Industry,Free Speech,Freedom Of The Press,New York Times Bias,Project Veritas,Media Bias,1st Amendment

From the Left
Opinion

Half a century ago, the Supreme Court settled the matter of when a court can stop a newspaper from publishing. In 1971, the Nixon administration attempted to block The Times and The Washington Post from publishing classified Defense Department documents detailing the history of the Vietnam War β€” the so-called Pentagon Papers. Faced with an asserted threat to the nation’s security, the Supreme Court sided with the newspapers. β€œWithout an informed and free press, there cannot be an enlightened people,” Justice Potter Stewart wrote in a concurring opinion.

That sentiment reflects one of the oldest and most enduring principles in our legal system: The government may not tell the press what it can and cannot publish. This principle long predates the Constitution, but so there would be no mistake, the nation’s founders included a safeguard in the Bill of Rights anyway. The First Amendment says, β€œCongress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.”

This is why virtually every official attempt to bar speech or news reporting in advance, known as a prior restraint, gets struck down. β€œAny system of prior restraints of expression comes to this court bearing a heavy presumption against its constitutional validity,” the Supreme Court said in a 1963 case. Such restraints are β€œthe very prototype of the greatest threat to First Amendment values,” Justice Antonin Scalia wrote a generation later.

AllSides Picks

More News about Media Industry

News from the Left

News from the Center

News from the Right